18-year delay shouldn’t sink convent land claim, court told
Counsel for two missionary groups argues that the law governing land titles in Melaka and Penang sets no time limit for obtaining replacement titles.
The Court of Appeal in Malaysia has ruled that a 18-year delay should not invalidate a land claim made by two missionary organisations over a plot in Banda Hilir, currently owned by Sacred Heart Canossian Convent. The High Court had dismissed the challenge, ruling the organisations had failed to prove ownership. The Court of Appeal heard arguments that the judge erred by emphasizing the alleged delay, which the respondents had not raised.
The National Land Code does not impose a time limit for obtaining a replacement title, as the Limitation Act does not apply to Melaka and Penang's land laws. The two organisations - Canossian Sisters and Portuguese Mission - sought legal recourse in 2022 as there was no board to obtain a replacement title. The disputed Lot 6 was not state land, and they had been occupying it. The Court of Appeal reserved its decision.
Rewritten by urgent.news; may contain errors — check the original.
Other reports of this story
- 18-year delay shouldn’t sink convent land claim, court told freemalaysiatoday.com