Urgent.News

What's breaking now, across thousands of outlets.

AI

The philosophical reason AI Christmas ads leave audiences feeling cold

It's that time of year when Christmas ads start appearing, and brands offer up a slice of consumerist comfort as you curl up in front of a screen.

The philosophical reason AI Christmas ads leave audiences feeling cold

As Christmas advertisements increasingly incorporate artificial intelligence, audiences are growing wary of these technologically generated campaigns. A prime example unfolded last year in the Netherlands when McDonald's hastily pulled an AI-generated ad after three days due to backlash over undisclosed use. This year, brands like Coca-Cola and Plusnet have continued down this path, though U.K. law doesn't necessitate on-screen AI disclosure.

The Advertising Standards Authority frowns upon misleading omissions that imply human creation when, in fact, AI generated the content.

Increasingly, AI isn't just seen in the on-screen images, but also in the audio. Royal Mail's 2025 Christmas ad, for instance, featured an AI voiceover narration, raising concerns among industry insiders and the public. Even traditional animation is under scrutiny; Dior's festive short film, while appearing hand-drawn, utilized AI-driven automated interpolation. Viewers noted unusual hand transitions, leading some to believe AI was involved, despite the company's insistence otherwise.

The backlash raises profound ethical questions. AI models are trained on artists' work without compensation, potentially displacing human creators and harming communities and the environment. Moreover, presenting AI-generated content as human-created misrepresents the creative process, diminishing the aesthetic experience for viewers. Philosophers argue that forgeries damage the appreciation of art, suggesting the same applies to AI ads.

Despite these concerns, some brands are being transparent about their methods. Prada's campaign highlights traditional hand-drawn animation, while Barbour and Thatchers Cider employed Aardman Studios for hand-animation. These examples suggest audiences value authenticity and craftsmanship, and AI-generated content may not satisfy this demand. As we enter the holiday season, the debate over AI in advertising will likely intensify, with the industry grappling with the balance between innovation and ethical responsibility.

Written by urgent.news from Phys.org's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.

Read the original at phys.org →

More in AI

More from Thursday 19 November →