Urgent.News

What's breaking now, across thousands of outlets.

Business

OPINIÃO. Quem atende o cliente no sexto dia?

Daqui a quatro semanas, numa quarta-feira, 16 de dezembro, cerca de 700 mil comerciários de São Paulo e Porto Alegre começam a trabalhar cinco dias e folgar dois, por acordos que os sindicatos fecharam antes mesmo de a regra nacional apertar. A troca chega justamente no mês em que o varejo mais vende, e qualquer gerente de loja já está pensando no sábado antes do Natal – quando a escala, pela…

On December 16, approximately 700,000 workers in São Paulo and Porto Alegre will start a six-day workweek followed by two days of rest, as per agreements reached by trade unions before the national rule took effect. The change comes in a month when retail sales are highest, and retailers are already planning for Saturday sales after the Christmas holiday.

President Lula signed the decree regulating the transition under Constitutional Amendment 141, which was passed by Congress in October. The maximum workweek drops from 44 to 42 hours in December and to 40 hours in December 2027, with two days of rest per week and no salary reduction. Whether one agrees with the decision or not, it has already been made.

The practical question for store operators is how to continue serving the same customers on the same schedule with fewer people available. According to the Ministry of Labor, 14.8 million employees work on a six-one shift, one in every three signed workers. The shift is concentrated in daily-operating sectors, affecting 42.2% of employment contracts, 47.1% of food services, and 52% of hospitality.

When looking at individual occupations, salespeople, cashiers, and store attendants come to mind. Not all six-one workers are on the sales floor, but the shift has the most impact on customer service. A technical note from Ipea, the most conservative estimate, calculates that a 40-hour workweek raises the average celetista's cost by 7.84% and adds 1.04% to the operational cost of retail businesses, which employ nearly 7 million formal jobs.

Industry entities report even larger increases, as they include staffing needs to cover seven-day stores that previously operated five days a week: the IDV estimates a 20% to 22% rise in personnel expenses, while the CNC projects an annual cost of R$122.4 billion for retail. The implications for business results become clear in market analyses.

Fitch Ratings expects a 10% to 15% drop in EBITDA for retailers, with margins potentially two percentage points lower without compensation, and identifies pharmacies and shopping malls as the most exposed. Ipea and Fitch numbers do not contradict each other, as a 1% cost increase in a 8% to 10% margin sector translates to about a tenth of operational profit.

Economists consulted by the Central Bank predict a 0.3 percentage point increase in inflation and a 0.2 percentage point reduction in growth in 2027, with the Copom citing the new work schedule among factors driving prices. Hiring more staff or paying overtime increases operations costs, and the CNC acknowledges that consumer income cannot fully pass through to prices.

Reducing working hours may seem like a simple solution, but closing stores earlier to save on labor can cost more in lost revenue. The new work schedule has increased the cost of human customer service for the first time since the 1988 Constitution, changing the equation for any technology aiming to free up store hours. An AI that chats with customers makes sense when it takes over tasks that don't require a person in the store, without replacing anyone.

Intravenous care and answering customer questions via WhatsApp are tasks that can build relationships and should not be replaced by anyone. The new work schedule reduces the hours when people are available to serve customers, but it does not reduce the hours when customers want to be served. An AI can maintain the relationship when the salesperson is busy, the team is reduced, or the store is closed.

It can help optimize the essential human work that the new schedule essentially requires: optimizing human work that is largely physical. In the store, the salesperson, who now costs more per hour, focuses on tasks that only physical presence can offer, such as consulting high-ticket items or handling indecisive customers. In WhatsApp, the same relationship continues with the assistant, who functions as a digital extension of the salesperson, answering 24/7 with the same level of service, and transferring conversations to a human when in-person assistance is needed.

This reorganization does not eliminate the need for human labor, particularly in cleaning, restocking, and visual merchandising, which will continue to rely on human presence for some time. Therefore, customer service deserves increased urgency: treating the new schedule as merely an HR issue will leave retailers struggling with staffing issues in 2027.

Those who view the transition as merely a human resources problem will face staffing challenges as 2027 approaches. Those who use AI for customer service at the store already consider it a mature area, but it now becomes an operational concern. The new work schedule makes it clear that someone must attend to customers on the sixth day.

Written by urgent.news from Brazil Journal's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.

Read the original at braziljournal.com →

More in Business

More from Thursday 19 November →