Urgent.News

What's breaking now, across thousands of outlets.

Finance & Markets

Mum awarded RM400,000 for loss of earnings after son drowns at hotel

Parents’ cross-appeal succeeds, with Court of Appeal also dismissing hotel operators’ appeal against High Court’s RM1 million damages award.

Mum awarded RM400,000 for loss of earnings after son drowns at hotel

In a recent ruling, the Court of Appeal has awarded a Singaporean mother approximately RM400,000 for loss of earning capacity after her son tragically drowned in a hotel jacuzzi eight years ago. The appellate court overturned the High Court's decision that there was insufficient evidence to establish that the mother faced risks of job loss or having to accept lower-paid employment.

Justice Azizul Azmi Adnan explained that claimants can prove loss of earning capacity by demonstrating that a medical condition disrupted their career or impeded their ability to continue in their current employment. Medical evidence unequivocally indicated that the mother experienced post-traumatic stress disorder and major depressive disorder following the incident.

These conditions were persistent, described as resistant to treatment by medical experts, and had significantly impacted her life. Consequently, the court granted the mother RM119,280 in damages for loss of earning capacity, including accrued interest at 5% per annum from the filing date to the settlement date. However, the court declined the parents' request for aggravated damages, as the trial court had not concluded that the hotel operators had engaged in aggravating conduct that caused the jacuzzi's vortex cover to malfunction.

Additionally, the court dismissed the hotel operators' appeal against the damages awarded by the High Court, ordering them to pay RM70,000 in costs. The case originated from the Sunway Putra Hotel in August 2018 when the mother's son, Adel, became trapped underwater after being drawn into the jacuzzi's suction outlet, which had become exposed due to the anti-vortex cover's dislodgement.

The High Court determined that the tragedy was exacerbated by inadequate maintenance and the hotel staff's failure to deactivate the facility during the emergency. The Singaporean parents had sued the hotel operators for negligence and breach of contract, alleging psychological trauma and the need for psychiatric treatment following their son's demise.

During the proceedings, Liew Teck Huat and Sufiah Yusoff represented the parents, while Gavrie Ang, Kieran Dass, and Edmund Choi acted on behalf of the hotel operators.

Written by urgent.news from Free Malaysia Today's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.

Read the original at freemalaysiatoday.com →

More in Finance & Markets

More from Thursday 19 November →