Urgent.News

What's breaking now, across thousands of outlets.

Culture

MISSION IMPOSSIBLE: Rassie’s ‘knee-drop’ complaint — how rugby’s complex laws hobble accurate officiating

Springbok coach Rassie Erasmus’ now infamous media conference, where he used the term ‘match-fixing’, raises uncomfortable questions for the custodians of the game.

MISSION IMPOSSIBLE: Rassie’s ‘knee-drop’ complaint — how rugby’s complex laws hobble accurate officiating

Rugby officials face a difficult task when evaluating whether a "knee-drop" tackle is legal or not. In a recent controversial incident during a Test match between Springboks and France, Springbok centre Damian de Allende made a tackle where his knee appeared to be slightly off the ground in the final split second before contact. According to World Rugby's laws, this tackle was deemed legal, but Springbok coach Rassie Erasmus disagreed and cited 17 similar instances he believed were illegal.

The challenge lies in the fact that officials must make split-second decisions while surrounded by moving bodies and from a single angle. Additionally, the tackle can be close to head-on-head contact, which is another offence. Fans are arguing over the marginality of such cases, demanding perfection from officials in real-time. When the television match official (TMO) didn't step in to adjudicate these tackles, Erasmus took it personally, directing his frustration at both the referee and the TMO.

The knee-drop tackle highlights the complexity of World Rugby's lawbook, which contains 21 basic laws and roughly 320 sub-clauses. Referees face numerous judgment calls during a game, including determining when a ruck has formed, the offside lines, and whether to play advantage or stop play. While referees have always made these calls, the knee-drop law adds another layer of complexity, as it requires officials to determine if the tackler's knee hits the ground before contact or at the same moment.

The issue stems from World Rugby's attempts to minimize stoppages and keep the ball in play, which limited the TMO's intervention to only "clear and obvious" situations. However, the knee-drop tackle happens so quickly that it's often unnoticeable to the naked eye, creating a dilemma. As a result, the one official with the tools to judge a knee-drop properly – the TMO – has been essentially told to stay out of it.

Written by urgent.news from Daily Maverick's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.

Read the original at dailymaverick.co.za →

More in Culture

Christopher Nolan Throws Cold Water on ‘The Odyssey’ Director’s Cut

“I wanna stand behind the cuts of the films that are put out there,” the filmmaker says of his blockbuster epic The post Christopher Nolan Throws Cold Water on ‘The Odyssey’ Director’s Cut appeared…

  • Nolan dismisses director's cut for 'The Odyssey'
  • Believes theatrical release is important
  • Focuses on eliminating unnecessary scenes during filming

More from Thursday 19 November →