Urgent.News

What's breaking now, across thousands of outlets.

World

CFP committee needs to show its work after Alabama over UCLA ranking

Alabama is 8-2. UCLA is 10-0. And in the latest College Football Playoff (CFP) rankings that were released on Tuesday night, the Crimson Tide came in one spot (No. 3) ahead of the Bruins (No. 4) for a second straight week. That is just one of the many things that has fueled debate the last […]

CFP committee needs to show its work after Alabama over UCLA ranking

The College Football Playoff (CFP) committee's ranking system has come under scrutiny after Alabama and UCLA were placed in the same position (No. 3 and No. 4) for the second consecutive week. This has led to speculation that the committee may be biased towards the Southeastern Conference (SEC) over the Big Ten, Big 12, and Atlantic Coast Conference (ACC). While the committee may not necessarily be biased, the lack of transparency in the ranking process fuels these suspicions.

The committee's decision-making process is shrouded in mystery, with executive director Rich Clark stating that they have not publicly disclosed the metrics used to determine the rankings. Clark acknowledges that providing these metrics publicly would be challenging, but the lack of transparency has left fans questioning the validity of the rankings.

One metric that the committee values is strength of schedule, with Alabama ranking sixth in strength of schedule according to ESPN's Football Power Index (FPI). This metric may appear reasonable to casual fans, but using ESPN's own metrics raises concerns about potential bias. Additionally, head-to-head results may not be a significant factor in the committee's decision-making, as seen in Alabama's ranking ahead of Tennessee despite the Volunteers defeating them by 16 points this season.

The committee's non-disclosure of the specific metrics used has made it difficult for fans to understand how the rankings are determined. This has led to a perception that the rankings are influenced by external factors, such as media coverage and the dominance of the SEC. To address these concerns, the CFP Committee should be transparent about the metrics they use and the reasons behind their selection.

By publishing a methodology upfront, the committee can build trust with fans and provide a clear explanation for any changes made during the season.

Written by urgent.news from SB Nation's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.

Read the original at sbnation.com →

More in World

Honouring Pravin Gordhan — a call for a new progressive movement in SA

Mcebisi Jonas reflects on global electoral shifts, South Africa’s political fragmentation and the urgent need to rebuild progressive politics.

  • Former deputy minister Mcebisi Jonas delivered poignant speech at UCT memorial.
  • Jonas lamented decline of democracy and rise of autocracies worldwide.
  • Praised Gordhan's leadership for progressive movement beyond opposition.

More from Thursday 19 November →