Urgent.News

What's breaking now, across thousands of outlets.

Tech

Apple fires back at Epic over claims it withheld 122,000 documents

Apple has responded to Epic Games’ filing from last Friday, pushing back against accusations that it improperly withheld more than 122,000 documents related to its proposed App Store commissions. Here are the details. more…

Apple fires back at Epic over claims it withheld 122,000 documents

Apple has responded to Epic Games' recent filing, countering claims that it withheld over 122,000 documents related to proposed App Store commissions. The dispute stems from a recent lawsuit where the Supreme Court is reviewing the validity of a civil contempt designation against Apple. In August, Apple submitted a proposal to the district court suggesting commission rates ranging from 5% to 15% on purchases made through external payment systems.

Epic disputes not only the rationale behind these rates but also Apple's management of document production in the proceedings. Epic submitted 16 categories of documents it requested Apple to produce, including internal analyses of the financial impact of proposed commissions and communications about strategies to discourage developers from using link-outs.

Apple agreed to use Epic's search terms and included all relevant employees in the production. However, Epic alleges Apple withheld more than 122,000 documents matching Epic's search terms from the records of seven initial employees and is asking the court to compel the production of all non-privileged matching documents. Apple argues that Epic's search terms were overly broad, capturing numerous irrelevant documents, such as references to unrelated terms like "commissioner" or "feedback."

Moreover, Apple contends that over 95% of the identified documents did not pertain to the central issue of "link-out fees," and even contained sensitive information like tax records or privileged communications. The company emphasizes that it is only required to produce documents directly related to the discovery request, not every document that contains a search term.

Apple also highlights that complying with Epic's demands would involve significant additional work, including redacting sensitive information, potentially making it impossible to meet the proposed deadline of December 2. Instead, Apple proposes submitting a randomized sample of nonresponsive documents to a Special Master for independent review if the court deems intervention necessary.

Written by urgent.news from 9to5Mac's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.

Read the original at 9to5mac.com →

More in Tech

More from Thursday 19 November →