Urgent.News

What's breaking now, across thousands of outlets.

World

To shoot or not: rethinking police use of lethal force in a civil society

Protecting police officers and protecting the public are not competing goals but complementary responsibilities of a professional law enforcement service.

To shoot or not: rethinking police use of lethal force in a civil society

The recent directive from the Kuala Lumpur police chief about police officers firing when encountering threats, even with doubts or feeling threatened, sparks an important discussion about the use of firearms in a civil democratic society. The directive came in response to a serious machete attack in Gombak, highlighting the need to protect police officers while also evaluating the broader implications of a "shoot-first" approach.

In a civil society, the use of lethal force by law enforcement must align with democratic policing principles. While officers are expected to protect the public and enforce the law, their right to self-defence must be matched with a clear understanding of when using firearms is justified. The determining factor should not solely be the officer's perception of threat, but whether the threat is immediate and serious enough to warrant lethal force.

There is a critical distinction between perceived threats, actual threats, and imminent threats to life. Subjective apprehension alone cannot justify discharging a firearm. The nature of the threat, the individual's actions, available alternatives, and immediate danger to others must be objectively assessed. International standards, including those from the United Nations, stress the necessity, proportionality, and restraint in the use of force and firearms by law enforcement.

A policy encouraging officers to shoot at the slightest uncertainty could lead to unnecessary fatalities, erode public confidence, and subject officers and the police institution to legal scrutiny. It's essential that police forces in democratic societies provide structured use-of-force frameworks that prioritize de-escalation, conflict management, and alternatives to lethal force whenever possible.

In Malaysia, this conversation should lead to greater transparency regarding police standing orders, firearms policies, and the procedures surrounding the discharge of weapons. Public confidence hinges on the proper documentation and investigation of firearm incidents, with independent scrutiny where fatalities or serious injuries occur. While officers have the right and responsibility to protect themselves and the public, they must not be put in a position where they expose others to avoidable danger.

Continuous training in firearms and the use of lethal force is crucial. This training should not be a one-time event during basic training, but should be ongoing, regularly assessed, and updated to reflect changing criminal threats, operational realities, technological advancements, and international best practices. The standard operating procedures governing firearms and lethal force must also be periodically reviewed and updated as necessary, providing clear and practical guidance on when lethal force is legally justified and necessary.

Ultimately, the protection of police officers and the public are complementary responsibilities of a professional law enforcement service. Officers should not be expected to risk their lives unnecessarily, nor should the public face an unrestricted use of lethal force. The key question is not whether police should shoot, but whether the circumstances objectively justify lethal force.

In a civil democratic society, decisive action is necessary when confronting genuine and imminent threats to life, while restraint, professionalism, continuous training, and accountability must remain integral to the exercise of law enforcement authority. The legitimacy of policing depends on knowing when the use of force is justified and when it is not.

Written by urgent.news from Free Malaysia Today's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.

Read the original at freemalaysiatoday.com →

More in World

More from Wednesday 18 November →