'Perfectionist' as a label: Who claims it and who doesn't
It's a label people casually toss around in conversations about school, work and life in general: "perfectionist." But do young adults who call themselves perfectionists exhibit the behaviors and psychological traits associated with perfectionism?
The study led by Brock University suggests that young adults who label themselves as perfectionists do indeed exhibit behaviors and psychological traits consistent with perfectionism. However, the researchers found that the social identities and backgrounds of these individuals also play a significant role in their willingness to adopt the label.
Unlike their earlier research, the team did not specifically target perfectionists for this latest study; instead, they aimed to understand if individuals gave themselves the label due to its generally positive connotations, such as the perception of perfectionism as a sign of competence and high achievement.
The study involved 988 participants aged 18 to 25 from the U.S., chosen to reflect the country's population demographics. Participants were asked if they considered themselves perfectionists and answered questions from three validated psychological scales that measured different aspects of perfectionism. These scales assessed traits such as concern over mistakes, setting high personal standards, parental expectations, experiences of parental criticism, doubts about actions, being organized, self-oriented perfectionism, other-oriented perfectionism, and socially prescribed perfectionism.
The researchers also distinguished between perfectionism, the tendency to strive for flawlessly high standards, and excellencism, the pursuit of high yet achievable personal standards with a flexible approach.
The findings indicated that self-identifying as a perfectionist was linked to higher scores on these validated perfectionism scales. Specifically, women and individuals identifying as 2SLGBTQIA+ were more likely to adopt the label. Moreover, the association between the self-label and measured perfectionism was stronger among participants from lower socioeconomic backgrounds.
The researchers note that this study marks the beginning of a broader exploration into the development of perfectionism over time, particularly in the unique Canadian context, which may influence how young people experience pressure and conform to societal expectations.
Written by urgent.news from Medical Xpress's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.