MISSING BEDS: St Luke’s hospice unit closure — Has dying without dignity become acceptable?
The closure of the St Luke’s Combined Hospices’ Inpatient Unit in December 2024 has left us with a question that cannot be answered by statistics alone: Where does a person with a life-limiting illness go when their symptoms become too difficult to manage at home, the family is exhausted and at breaking point, there is no medical aid, and there is no hospice bed available?
In December 2024, the Inpatient Unit at St Luke's Combined Hospices closed its doors, leaving a critical question unanswered: where should individuals with life-limiting illnesses go when their symptoms become too overwhelming to manage at home, the family is exhausted, there is no medical aid, and no hospice bed is available? This facility, which had provided compassionate and person-centred care for over four decades, stands empty, while those facing the end of their lives continue to suffer and families struggle to find suitable care.
Former St Luke's staff and volunteers, known as Put Patients First, are raising their concerns once more, as the real issue being debated is often overlooked. The 'people prefer to die at home' argument is presented as a universal solution, despite not accounting for the realities faced by many patients and the limitations of the public health system. Caring for a dying person is physically and emotionally draining, and families may lack proper beds, utilities, and the ability to rest while providing care.
St Luke's claimed to care for an average of three to five patients, while community-based services handle "600 on any given day." However, these figures may not accurately reflect the situation, as the unit faced financial difficulties and reduced staff, leading to a waiting list and limited care. Alternative facilities, such as transitional care facilities and private NGOs, are not adequate replacements, as they do not provide the same level of specialized care and support for end-of-life patients.
The ground reality paints a grim picture, with families left with little option but to call an ambulance or place their loved one in a cold and lonely emergency ward bed.
Written by urgent.news from Daily Maverick's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.