Urgent.News

What's breaking now, across thousands of outlets.

AI

‘Just Ridiculous’: A Famed Philosopher Takes on AI Consciousness

Thomas Nagel has done landmark work on consciousness in nonhumans; this week, he won the million-dollar Berggruen Prize for his contributions to the field. And he has a lot of thoughts on AI.

‘Just Ridiculous’: A Famed Philosopher Takes on AI Consciousness

The renowned philosopher Thomas Nagel, 89 years old and a university professor emeritus at NYU, recently engaged in a conversation about the implications of artificial intelligence on his views on consciousness. While applauding the lifelike nature of large language models, Nagel finds the notion that they might be conscious or soon become so to be "ridiculous."

He argues that functionalism, which posits that consciousness is linked to physical processes and systems of certain kinds, is more likely to be the truth. However, he remains skeptical about the emergence of consciousness in substrates that are materially distinct from the human nervous system.

Nagel emphasizes that consciousness is inherently subjective and that we lack the imaginative capacity to comprehend the subjective experiences of entities like large language models. While bats are known to be conscious, the same cannot be concluded about AI systems, as their language production does not equate to natural manifestations of consciousness.

Nagel also cautions against the commercial incentives that may drive the belief in AI consciousness, urging that such systems should not be granted mental life that they do not possess.

The philosopher acknowledges the complexity of the issue and the potential for future developments, such as the creation of lifelike androids. He remains concerned about the societal impact of these technological advancements and the potential consequences of treating AI as conscious beings. Nagel's philosophical ideas are gaining significant attention and influence, but he believes that the current perspective on AI consciousness is misguided and may have detrimental effects on public discourse.

Written by urgent.news from Wired's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.

Read the original at wired.com →

More in AI

Investors Should Beware Anthropic's IPO

Ken Fisher, billionaire investor and founder of Fisher Investments, talks about Anthropic, Nvidia and the risk in private credit.

  • Investors should wait for better entry point when buying Anthropic shares.
  • AI sector valuations may decline in short term.
  • Treasury Secretary's Nvidia comments are outside his role.

More from Wednesday 18 November →