I've Been Wrong About Paypal Stock for 2 Years. Here's Why I'm Finally Changing My Mind.
PayPal raised its 2026 guidance as Venmo and AI-powered commerce gain traction. Here's what could keep the turnaround going, and what could stall it.
For the past two years, investors have been wary of PayPal (PYPL -1.22%). Their skepticism stems from the company's sluggish growth and fierce competition. However, recently, PayPal has raised its full-year adjusted earnings guidance following a stronger-than-expected performance. With Venmo's growth potential and the company's push into AI-powered commerce, PayPal might be on the verge of turning a corner.
Under new CEO Enrique Lores, PayPal is undergoing a transformation aimed at simplifying operations, enhancing accountability, and discovering new growth avenues. Rather than heavily relying on its traditional checkout business, management is exploring ways to maximize value from its ecosystem, including Venmo, merchant processing, and consumer financial services.
Initial signs are positive. Management has noted improving momentum in several key growth businesses, indicating that efforts to reverse the decline are beginning to bear fruit. Nonetheless, PayPal still faces several risks. Its branded checkout business remains a concern, with a mere 1% growth in the third quarter, pointing to intense competition from other payment providers.
Moreover, the company is grappling with execution risks as it reshapes its operations and expands consumer financial services. Nevertheless, the combination of a more focused strategy and improved execution provides investors with a reason to reconsider PayPal's long-term prospects, particularly as it unveils new ways to foster growth, starting with Venmo.
Notably, Venmo has evolved into a comprehensive consumer financial platform, driven by its expansion into debit cards, merchant payments, and other financial services. This is significant because each new use case presents another revenue-generating opportunity for PayPal from an existing customer relationship. In fact, Venmo's payment volume surged by 14% year-over-year during the third quarter of 2026, marking its eighth consecutive quarter of double-digit growth and solidifying its position as one of the company's strongest growth drivers.
Moreover, its 'Pay with Venmo' feature experienced a 43% increase, signaling that consumers are utilizing the platform for routine purchases, not just for money transfers. Looking ahead, PayPal's Venmo platform could become a substantial contributor to the company's earnings recovery if management successfully capitalizes on the platform's additional revenue streams.
However, Venmo is not the sole area exhibiting promise. PayPal is also exploring what could become its next significant growth opportunity: AI-powered commerce. With consumers discovering products through AI platforms, there is an ongoing need for dependable methods to complete purchases. PayPal has already forged partnerships with Microsoft to develop Copilot Checkout and with Alphabet to support Google's Universal Commerce Protocol (UCP).
Additionally, the company has been enhancing its capabilities through its acquisition of Cymbio, a commerce orchestration platform that enables merchants to make their products available across AI-driven shopping channels. If this novel shopping model gains traction, PayPal could reap benefits from a new source of payment activity while aiding merchants in reaching customers across multiple digital platforms.
In summary, PayPal is pursuing these newer opportunities alongside its ongoing efforts to bolster the profitability of its existing consumer and merchant businesses. Venmo, AI-powered commerce, and a stronger emphasis on execution offer PayPal several avenues to reignite growth. Currently, at a forward price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio of just 9.9, PayPal appears undervalued, suggesting that investors have priced in significant skepticism about its recovery.
If management manages to sustain the turnaround and consistently boost earnings, there is potential for a significant price increase as investor confidence grows, resulting in a higher valuation multiple for each dollar of earnings. While the turnaround remains uncertain, for the first time in a while, investors now have grounds for optimism.
When The Motley Fool's analyst team recommends a stock, it's worth heeding. After all, Stock Advisor's average return is an impressive 802%*—a substantial outperformance compared to the S&P 500's 205%. They've recently disclosed their top 10 stock picks for investors to consider right now, available upon joining Stock Advisor.
Written by urgent.news from Motley Fool's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.