Urgent.News

What's breaking now, across thousands of outlets.

AI

I Watched AI Eat the Easy Half of an Industry. The Other Half Got More Expensive.

AI is automating logistics analysis, but execution and domain expertise are gaining value. Discover how the shift is reshaping logistics consulting.

I Watched AI Eat the Easy Half of an Industry. The Other Half Got More Expensive.

The most striking example of AI's impact on the logistics consulting industry was observed in machine learning's gradual absorption of half of the work that was once billed to clients. Rather than disappearing, the analysts adjusted as the market split, with the half that survived becoming increasingly valuable. The computable aspects of the profession, such as benchmarking freight rates, modeling distribution networks, and forecasting demand curves, could now be completed at near-zero marginal cost by AI models.

This transformation was not immediately apparent. It first showed up as pricing pressure on commodity studies, then as procurement departments canceling retainers for tasks their own tools could now accomplish, and finally as mid-tier consulting firms pivoting to implementation or merging with acquiring companies. Within roughly three years, capable AI models had restructured the logistics consulting market.

The half of the industry that got "eaten" was the report-writing tier, whose deliverables were the analysis itself. This part of the profession was hollowed out, as clients were now receiving analysis that used to cost six figures for a fraction of the price, thanks to AI-fed software subscriptions. The report-writing layer is now being replaced by the expertise business, which scales with reps who negotiate and implement changes, rather than hiring junior analysts.

However, the non-computable layer of professional services did not shrink. Instead, it became the entire product, and its price went up. This is due to complementarity—the concept that when one input becomes automated, the complements it depends on appreciate in value. In the logistics industry, the unique and stubborn non-computable layer is specific to human interactions, such as negotiations and relationship management.

A model may identify overpaying on a freight lane, but it cannot mediate the complex human negotiations that follow.

The market has responded to this shift by re-prioritizing demand. Rankings of the top logistics consulting firms now emphasize execution-focused specialists rather than traditional report factories. Emerging boutiques built by industry operators, utilizing the same AI tools as their competitors, are thriving by offering the irreplaceable human judgment that AI cannot replicate. Many of these new firms tie their fees to documented savings, confident that their expertise cannot be replicated by software.

This shift has also influenced procurement departments, which once compared consulting firms based on day rates. Now, they evaluate firms based on outcome-driven references, as the automated layer is now software-driven. Consequently, the RFP questions have evolved from asking about methodology to requesting proof of the tangible results achieved in the last three engagements.

For builders of AI products in operational industries, the key takeaway is the two-fold strategy: first, sell to the experts who possess the domain judgment necessary to act on the AI-generated insights; and second, tailor your product to the interface between the model output and the complex human systems that must execute on that output. This approach acknowledges that while AI can automate certain computations, the human element remains essential in translating those outputs into actionable decisions.

Written by urgent.news from HackerNoon's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.

Read the original at hackernoon.com →

More in AI

China's Xi airs concern over unilateralism, seeks cooperation in AI

SHENZHEN, China (Kyodo) -- Chinese President Xi Jinping on Wednesday expressed concern that "unilateralism and protectionism are rampant" in the world

  • Chinese President Xi Jinping expressed concern over unilateralism and protectionism at APEC summit.
  • He advocated for cooperation in digital economy and AI, promoting equality-based multipolar world.
  • Xi stressed adherence to WTO rules and free trade to maintain global industry stability.

More from Wednesday 18 November →