Urgent.News

What's breaking now, across thousands of outlets.

Tech

I stopped using music streaming for a month, and found out how difficult owning music has become

And there are albums/songs you'd never be able to own (legally).

I stopped using music streaming for a month, and found out how difficult owning music has become

For years, I had been subscribing to music streaming services, yet I never truly owned any of the music I listened to. This realization prompted me to attempt a month-long experiment in building my own music library. Equipped with a home server, I planned to purchase and download my favorite albums, organize them, and listen to them using Plexamp, a music player compatible with Plex Media Server. Although the concept seemed simple, I soon realized the complexities of owning music in the modern era.

The first hurdle was locating suitable music for purchase. While Spotify offers a vast selection, buying individual tracks or albums is a completely different story. Stores such as Bandcamp, Qobuz, and the iTunes Store sell downloadable music, but none provides an all-encompassing catalog. I had to check multiple sources to find specific albums, only to discover that some of the songs or albums I desired were not available for purchase at all.

Bandcamp, which allows artists to sell their work directly to fans, was my initial destination. Its strong emphasis on independent artists, however, meant I couldn't rely on it for mainstream music. Qobuz, with its extensive collection of mainstream music, including high-resolution downloads, filled that gap—but it too had its limitations.

Paying for music also became more expensive. Even if an album cost $10, purchasing ten of them would amount to $100. I had to carefully consider which albums I genuinely loved and wanted to keep. Additionally, I had to pay close attention to the file formats I was buying. Lossless FLAC files were my preference, but not every store offered lossless downloads.

Once I had some music downloaded, organizing it and accessing it across my devices became the next challenge. With a home server at my disposal, I decided to use Plexamp, a music player designed to work with Plex Media Server. Creating a music library in Plex and pointing it to the folder containing my music seemed straightforward.

However, ensuring my collection looked and functioned like a proper music library required significant effort. Inconsistent file names, missing album artwork, and incorrect metadata presented obstacles. While Plex could automatically identify most albums, I still had to correct instances where tracks were associated with the wrong artist or album.

Organizing files into proper artist and album folders, especially for compilations and multiple releases from the same artist, also proved labor-intensive.

Despite these challenges, Plexamp delivered a polished experience. Its user-friendly interface, support for lossless playback, and features like smart playlists, gapless playback, and radio stations based on my collection made it a capable alternative to music streaming services. Moreover, I could access my music outside my home network, provided my server was running and I had a stable connection.

The shift in how music is consumed has altered the economics of listening to music. For the price of a single album, Spotify provides access to millions of songs for an entire month. Building a comparable collection by purchasing individual albums, however, is financially impractical. Even if one spends hundreds of dollars, the resulting collection would likely be a fraction of the music accessible through a streaming subscription.

Record labels and distributors have increasingly favored streaming, and many albums available on Spotify may not have a straightforward digital download option. This shift often means that even if an album is on Spotify, a legitimate download version may be scarce or nonexistent.

This situation highlights the complexities and challenges of owning music in today's digital landscape.

Written by urgent.news from XDA Developers's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.

Read the original at xda-developers.com →

More in Tech

More from Wednesday 18 November →