BNSF Files Detailed Opposition to UP-NS Merger
The filing with the Surface Transportation Board includes a brief supported by more than 130 exhibits, declarations from BNSF...
On November 18, freight rail company BNSF submitted its formal opposition to the proposed merger between Union Pacific (UP) and Norfolk Southern (NS) to the Surface Transportation Board (STB). This extensive filing, which includes over 130 exhibits, declarations from BNSF executives and experts, and detailed data, explains why BNSF contends the merger would diminish competition, increase shipping costs, and fail to provide promised benefits. The brief asserts, "UP will be UP — with more market power."
BNSF's previous concerns were detailed in a September 9 filing to the STB, which outlined conditions BNSF would seek to maintain competition if the merger were approved. However, the more recent filing on November 18 presents a comprehensive case against the merger, emphasizing BNSF's ongoing objections. Among their criticisms are questionable traffic projections, with BNSF identifying over 310 errors in UP/NS's traffic analysis, which questions the projected increase in truck-to-rail traffic.
Another concern is the limited shipper protections; BNSF argues that UP/NS's Committed Gateway Pricing program would only cover 0.9% of rail traffic.
The filing also highlights broad opposition to the merger. "Shipper groups representing more than 50% of rail cargo have opposed or raised concerns about the merger, while unions representing more than 70% of the projected combined unionized workforce oppose it," the document states. BNSF, as one of six major Class I freight railroads in the U.S., joins a coalition of stakeholders opposing the merger, alongside CSX Transportation, Canadian National Railway, and Canadian Pacific Kansas City.
Written by urgent.news from Supply Chain Brain's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.