Urgent.News

What's breaking now, across thousands of outlets.

World

Big Oil is weaponising the law, and it’s critical that Africa fights back

Communities who turn to the courts for justice are being drowned out with expensive lawsuits, lengthy litigation and damning labels. Big Oil and the extractive industry use the same law to drown vulnerable African nations in further debt.

Communities seeking justice from courts are often overwhelmed by costly lawsuits, protracted litigation, and derogatory labels. Large oil companies and the extractive industry utilize the same legal system to burden vulnerable African nations with additional debt. Ephraim Ozabor, media coordinator at the SA Comms Hub, highlights that on August 14, 2026, fishing communities from South Africa's Wild Coast successfully held an oil company accountable.

Global Fund for a New Economy's media unit, under which Ozabor works, reports that Shell, a major oil firm, and its partner Impact Africa had a right to explore for oil and gas off South Africa's Eastern Cape coast. The company intended to conduct seismic blasting, which would have used air guns to create sound blasts in the sea every ten seconds for four to five months, impacting the fishing communities' livelihoods.

Shell and its partners took the fishing communities to three courts, ultimately winning a landmark victory. This case marked the first time an African top court cited the International Court of Justice's 2025 ruling that governments have a legal duty to prevent climate harm. However, less discussed are the tactics Shell employed to counter the legal battle.

The Eastern Cape Division of the High Court in Makhanda initially set aside Shell's exploration right because the communities had not been adequately consulted. In response, Shell filed an appeal and attempted to renew the unlawful right without informing the communities. Despite the Supreme Court of Appeal ruling the right unlawful, the Constitutional Court ultimately dismissed it, emphasizing that financial investments should not outweigh severe constitutional violations.

The entire process took nearly five years of intense litigation, demonstrating how the law can become a weapon.

Oil giants like Shell win not by winning every legal round, but by ensuring the process is slow and their adversaries are hindered. They appeal, reapply through loopholes, and delay justice, costing fishing villages money and time that should be spent at sea and earning a living. In court, each month incurs expenses the communities cannot afford.

Shell views legal costs as mere line items. Most communities never initiate such fights, and those who do must outlast a company that can afford extensive legal resources. At the UN's COP31 in Antalya, Turkey, Secretary-General António Guterres urged governments to transition from discussing the energy transition to organizing it.

However, the fossil fuel industry is already organizing in courtrooms and parliaments to make climate action legally risky for anyone who tries.

Fishing communities facing such challenges are labeled as "anti-development," with their cases deemed "lawfare." Lawfare refers to the use of legal processes as a weapon, with multiple case filings and appeals aimed at exhausting opponents rather than seeking a genuine legal resolution. Climate groups face this label when court challenges delay fossil fuel projects.

The African Energy Chamber claimed in 2021 that Western-funded NGOs engaged in "lawfare." The label shifts focus from legal adherence to questioning the opposition's motives, portraying communities as obstacles to jobs and investment. However, the evidence shows that a successful, multi-level legal challenge, as in the Wild Coast case, is not "lawfare" but the proper enforcement of the law.

The oil industry is misusing the legal system to suppress those who challenge them, a regressive use that endangers the most vulnerable.

Written by urgent.news from Daily Maverick's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.

Read the original at dailymaverick.co.za →

More in World

More from Wednesday 18 November →