BABOONS OP-ED: Baboon capture came with a dodgy explanation — was this ethical window dressing?
After capturing the Waterfall troop, the authorities explained themselves in the language of ethics: a last resort, an alternative to culling, better welfare. Ethical language should be welcomed. But it came after the deed, it contradicts the ethical framework of their own Baboon Management Action Plan, and its moral reasoning has not been tested. Ethics is the hard work one does to make a…
On Thursday, CapeNature issued permits for the capture of a baboon troop in Simon's Town. By Friday evening, 27 baboons had been captured and taken to the Urban Wildlife Centre. On Saturday, another 18 were captured. One elderly female was euthanized, while the remaining 44 were confined to an enclosure. The City of Cape Town released a statement on Sunday, claiming the capture was a last resort and an alternative to culling, asserting it would improve welfare and acknowledging the moral cost.
However, this ethical explanation appears to have been added post-facto, contradicting the Baboon Management Action Plan's own framework. The plan itself poses ethical questions and suggests a different approach, but these concerns were not addressed until after the capture, raising questions about the ethical considerations behind the decision.
Written by urgent.news from Daily Maverick's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.