What the EU can learn from Mark Carney on digital sovereignty
Building autonomy does not mean countries need to isolate.
Former Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney urged Europe to embrace greater strategic autonomy amid rising great-power rivalry, rather than withdrawing behind borders. Carney advocated building capabilities while collaborating closely with like-minded allies, particularly in technology. This idea has started to shape EU policy following the EU-Canada Summit.
The two sides agreed to an "Alliance for the Future" and signed a Digital Trade Agreement to foster a secure, open and trusted digital environment. This approach benefits Europe's relationships with other trusted partners. Europe recognizes its over-reliance on a limited number of technology providers for cloud services, computing power, digital infrastructure, and AI models.
To address this, the European Commission aims to mobilize €200 billion toward AI and increase data center capacity by at least threefold within five to seven years. However, Europe might inadvertently exclude some heavy investors and dependent companies by narrowing the technology field. The European Cloud and AI Development Act aims to influence how Europe expands and safeguards its technological capabilities, but it may inadvertently limit the companies that can participate.
The debate over digital sovereignty should go beyond mere ownership or headquarters. Effective sovereignty requires that Europe can maintain essential services during crises, protect critical systems, and retain a choice of secure, trusted suppliers. When evaluating, policymakers should consider who controls data, encryption, operations, security, and continuity.
Corporate nationality, while relevant, cannot answer these questions alone. A cloud provider may be EU-owned but still depend on external processors, software, and security tools. Conversely, a company headquartered outside the EU might operate European data centers, employ European engineers, and comply with stringent European regulations.
In practice, sovereignty based on nationality should apply strictly to providers controlled from a country posing a recognized security threat or lacking the capacity and record of exploiting technological dependencies. Countries like Switzerland, Canada, and the UK should not be automatically considered threats. Instead, three tests should be applied: operational control in Europe, service continuity during crises, and substantial, long-term contributions to Europe's technological capacity.
These principles are particularly relevant for telecoms, where operators must keep essential services running through cyberattacks, power failures, and supply-chain disruptions while safeguarding EU data confidentiality. Registered addresses alone do not address these operational questions. This perspective extends beyond the Cloud and AI Development Act, potentially shaping EU policy on telecommunications, satellites, semiconductors, and other strategic technologies.
Rules that exclude trusted foreign investors primarily based on nationality risks market fragmentation and deters some of the capital and expertise Europe seeks to attract.
Written by urgent.news from Politico EU's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.