Umno’s political leverage weakens push for reform, say analysts
Syaza Shukri says Umno’s strength makes it possible for the party to ignore reforms, while James Chin says cooperation with PAS offers the party a path back to power without meaningful change.
Umno's political power has been diminishing, making it harder to push for reforms, according to analysts. Petaling Jaya: The party's ability to win voter support remains more crucial than its government records for potential coalition partners, analysts say. Syaza Shukri, a political analyst, believes stronger grassroots support would give Umno the upper hand when negotiating for positions in government, allowing them to ignore calls for accountability over past failures.
With short political cycles in Malaysia, instilling good governance for years to come is not a top priority, she added. Umno has effectively avoided linking itself directly to institutional failures, attributing these issues to individuals instead. Syaza warns against dismissing 1MDB, Tabung Haji, and the littoral combat ship (LCS) project failures as "old issues."
However, she notes that voters concerned about Umno's credibility might still question Pakatan Harapan (PH)'s as well. James Chin from the University of Tasmania suggests Umno might regain power without changing its internal culture if cooperation with PAS secures Malay support. He notes Umno briefly considered reform after the 2018 election but later found alliance-building viable.
Chin argues Umno can't change due to alliances and lack of accountability incentives. Cost-of-living pressures and voter attention could push accountability down their priorities, he adds. Awang Azman Pawi of Universiti Malaya proposes a different view, arguing parliamentary strength shouldn't be the only measure of a party's value, and past failures shouldn't permanently define its ability to govern.
He believes Umno could offer institutional knowledge, administrative continuity, and understanding of grassroots development needs. For Syaza, Umno has had an opportunity to demonstrate change through its federal administration participation, and acknowledging shortcomings would be a good start.
Written by urgent.news from Free Malaysia Today's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.