Quad9's withdrawal from France: A canary in the coal mine
Last month, the Swiss non-profit Quad9 announced it would withdraw its free public DNS resolver from France. This came after months of litigation and a French court ruling that imposed daily fines on Quad9 for not blocking alleged copyright-infringing domains. The organization faced an impossible choice - endure costly legal battles or alter its service in a way that would compromise user privacy and security.
Unable to find a satisfactory solution, Quad9 decided to withdraw. This move threatens the free and open Internet, exposing French users to potential disruptions and privacy risks. Quad9's resolver is utilized by various French entities, including government agencies, schools, hospitals, and utilities. If individuals and organizations fail to switch to another resolver before the withdrawal, their Internet access may be lost without warning.
The issue of public DNS resolvers being blocked is not unique to Quad9 or France. Cisco previously removed its OpenDNS resolver from France, Portugal, and Belgium under similar circumstances. A Belgian court has ordered major DNS providers like Cloudflare, Google, and Cisco to block specific websites starting early 2027, a request Cloudflare has consistently resisted.
This situation highlights the potential harm that maximal blocking efforts by rightsholders and policymakers can cause to the Internet. DNS resolvers are crucial components of the Internet's infrastructure, translating domain names into IP addresses for device connectivity. While any entity can operate a DNS resolver, they are often managed by ISPs, mobile networks, businesses, and educational institutions.
As a foundational part of the Internet, DNS resolvers must be reliable, trustworthy, and privacy-focused. Free public DNS resolvers, such as Cloudflare's 1.1.1.1 and Quad9's 9.9.9.9, offer fast, secure, and privacy-oriented alternatives. However, providing such services is technically demanding, requiring robust engineering and global distribution.
While rightsholders have legitimate concerns about combating online piracy, forcing DNS resolvers to block specific content is an ineffective and bypassable solution. Similar to an operator removing a business name from a phone book, it does not actually close the business. The only true way to address infringement is by removing the copyrighted material from the Internet.
Written by urgent.news from Hacker News's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.