NPA advocate says some foreigners play ‘catch me if you can’ with asylum claims
The ongoing case is testing whether the alleged asylum seekers can be detained while awaiting deportation.
A National Prosecuting Authority (NPA) advocate argued that South African authorities are dealing with foreigners who only claim asylum after being arrested. The ongoing case at the High Court in Johannesburg follows a Constitutional Court ruling invalidating parts of the Refugees Act. NPA attorney William Rasenga Mokhare SC contended that the state targets those who don't apply for asylum until after their arrest.
The court heard 33 consolidated urgent applications, stemming from conflicting rulings on the application of the Constitutional Court's Scalabrini judgment. NPA's Mokhare argued that the law allows detention of those who arrive illegally and claim asylum later, provided a magistrate authorizes the longer detention. However, the defence countered that asylum seekers are protected under the Refugees Act and cannot be held in detention, creating a conflict between legal frameworks.
The UNHCR representative for South Africa argued that the department's interpretation of the law goes against international law, as asylum seekers are protected from detention as soon as their intention to apply is known. Judge Lebogang Modiba questioned how the current law functions in practice, stating that an asylum seeker would receive a transit visa and temporary asylum permit once their application is lodged.
Written by urgent.news from The Citizen's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.