New study finds bosses who brag about their own good deeds risk disgusting their employees
A manager who talks about their own fairness and compassion can inspire employees or come across as self-righteous. New research across 254 workplace pairs and a controlled experiment suggests the difference lies in whether the boss also credits others.
A recent study published in the Journal of Applied Psychology reveals that a boss's self-promotion of ethical deeds at work can either inspire employees or come off as bragging. Researchers, Grace Ching Chi Ho and Hudson Sessions, from Southern Methodist University and Arizona State University respectively, looked into whether the inclusion of others' good deeds changes how employees react to their supervisor's moral stories.
Typically, when managers talk about their own professional accomplishments, employees perceive them as more competent but less warm and likable. Yet, the impact of bosses highlighting ethical conduct is less understood. This study distinguishes between "self-focused moral capitalization" (highlighting the boss's own ethical actions) and "other-focused moral capitalization" (focusing on the ethical actions of others).
The researchers suggest that when a boss boasts about their own ethical behavior, employees may feel either inspired or disgusted, depending on whether the boss also acknowledges the good deeds of others. The presence of others' good deeds may help mitigate any feelings of moral superiority in the boss, potentially leading to more helpful behavior from employees.
The study involved a three-wave survey of 305 supervisors and their employees, with the final sample of 254 supervisor-employee pairs. Results indicated that supervisors who frequently mentioned their own ethical actions tended to have employees who reported higher levels of moral elevation and, consequently, more helpful behavior.
Thus, while sharing personal ethical actions can inspire employees, doing so without acknowledging others' contributions might make the boss appear morally superior, leading to negative reactions. Balancing self-focused and other-focused moral capitalization may be key for supervisors aiming to foster a positive, ethical workplace culture.
Written by urgent.news from PsyPost's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.