Urgent.News

What's breaking now, across thousands of outlets.

World

French Jews need a future safe from the Left, and they aren't seeing one - editorial

Israel will always welcome French Jews who choose to make aliyah. But their departure is not a substitute for France doing its job.

The future of French Jews hangs in the balance as Jean-Luc Mélenchon emerges as a potential presidential candidate. A recent survey indicates that 69% of Jewish respondents may consider leaving France under that scenario, with 40% expressing a definite intention to depart. While these responses are hypothetical, they reflect a deep-seated fear of rising antisemitism under Mélenchon's leadership, a sentiment shared by 86% of Jewish respondents.

Mélenchon has vehemently denied any antisemitic tendencies, yet his past remarks and associations have fueled these concerns. For instance, his comments on the pronunciation of Jeffrey Epstein's name and his remarks about the name of Jewish politician Raphaël Glucksmann have drawn accusations of antisemitism, despite Mélenchon's subsequent apologies.

Mélenchon's allies are also under scrutiny. While some Left-wing politicians have challenged Mélenchon regarding antisemitism, others have dismissed the issue. It is crucial for both sides to clarify their stance and reassure Jewish voters that their safety and place in France are non-negotiable.

The survey also reveals that 31% of Jewish respondents could envision leaving if Marine Le Pen were to become president. Her party's history with Israel and antisemitism remains a contentious issue, yet French Jews should not be pressured into choosing the lesser of two evils.

Beyond politics, the survey shows that 82% of Jewish respondents have experienced antisemitic acts in their lifetime, leading many to alter their behavior to avoid drawing attention to their identity. This has resulted in difficult decisions, such as choosing what children can wear to school or whether to display a mezuzah at home. These are choices that should not require a constant assessment of personal safety.

Moreover, 79% of Jewish respondents have felt blamed or held responsible for the actions of the Israeli government, despite being French citizens and holding diverse views on the subject. Criticism of Israel is permissible, but blaming a Jewish individual or community for Israel's actions clearly constitutes antisemitism. Politicians advocating against prejudice must address this issue unequivocally.

France owes its Jewish citizens a future free from prejudice and fear. It is not sufficient to offer solidarity after an attack; schools must protect Jewish pupils, police and prosecutors must take threats seriously, and political parties must challenge antisemitism within their ranks, even when it is uncomfortable. While Israel will always welcome French Jews who choose to make aliyah, their departure should not be seen as a replacement for France fulfilling its responsibility to its Jewish citizens.

Written by urgent.news from Jerusalem Post's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.

Read the original at jpost.com →

More in World

Selena Gomez Prevails as Wondermind Investor Lawsuit Is Dismissed

"[Gomez] looks forward to moving forward," the actress' attorney says The post Selena Gomez Prevails as Wondermind Investor Lawsuit Is Dismissed appeared first on TheWrap .

  • Selena Gomez wins dismissal of her own Wondermind lawsuit
  • Co-founders Mandy Teefey and Daniella Pierson drop case
  • Accusations of $1.2M fraud and false promises dismissed with prejudice

More from Tuesday 17 November →