Clean Shipping Alliance Disappointed on Greenland’s scrubber ban
We are disappointed to see Greenland announce restrictions on exhaust gas cleaning systems (EGCS, or “scrubbers”), starting in 2027. Of course, protecting the Arctic’s sensitive marine environment is important, no question. What we haven’t yet understood, though, is what specific risk Greenland has identified from EGCS in its waters, and how that risk was assessed. ...
The Clean Shipping Alliance expressed disappointment over Greenland's plans to impose restrictions on exhaust gas cleaning systems, or scrubbers, starting in 2027. While the organization acknowledges the importance of safeguarding the Arctic's marine ecosystem, it remains unclear which specific risks Greenland identified in its waters and how it determined these risks.
The International Maritime Organization's (IMO) MEPC.1/Circ.899 outlines a standardized approach for evaluating local risks, encompassing factors such as the receiving environment, discharge composition, dilution, and ecotoxicity. The Clean Shipping Alliance urges Greenland to disclose its assessment if one was conducted, as failing to do so undermines the transparency required under the IMO framework.
The organization emphasizes that a precautionary approach, common in regions with scrubber restrictions, cannot override the necessity for an IMO-aligned assessment. The IMO's risk characterization and evaluation utilize internationally accepted methods, ensuring consistency in technical evaluations across countries. Studies, such as the recently published peer-reviewed assessment of Puget Sound, have found minimal or negligible risk from scrubbers under real-world operating conditions. This underscores the importance of context-specific assessments over blanket restrictions.
Greenland's proposed restrictions extend to territorial seas, surpassing OSPAR's current recommendations, and include limitations on closed-loop and hybrid scrubber systems from 2029. Operators need clarity on the basis of these restrictions and the specific risks each phase aims to address. The Clean Shipping Alliance calls for the IMO to reconsider its stance on a global ban in the Arctic, highlighting that most countries with existing EGCS restrictions have not undergone an IMO-aligned evaluation.
Regulation 4 of MARPOL Annex VI recognizes EGCS as an equivalent compliance method. The alliance argues that if governments seek to alter this regulation, they should pursue a transparent amendment at the IMO, backed by location-specific evidence rather than unilateral regional bans.
The alliance addresses a prevalent objection—that scrubbers merely transfer pollution from the air to the sea. In truth, EGCS effectively reduce sulphur and other harmful substances in exhaust gases, mitigating their release into the atmosphere, where they pose significant health risks, and depositing them in the ocean, where they naturally occur and quickly dissipate.
EGCS also contribute to lowering particulate matter, PAHs, and metal emissions in exhaust emissions, particularly near coastal areas, including ports and harbors. Comparatively, alternative solutions like marine gas oil (MGO) refine lifecycle CO2 emissions but add to environmental impacts, as evidenced by CE Delft's 2021 well-to-wake analysis.
Therefore, the proposed Nuuk-Reykjavik green corridor, reliant on MGO, does not ensure a superior environmental outcome compared to continued EGCS use.
Written by urgent.news from Hellenic Shipping News's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.