ATIR takes notice of fake adjournment granted by FBR official
ISLAMABAD: In an unprecedented matter, Multan Bench of Appellate Tribunal Inland Revenue (ATIR) has taken judicial notice where the assessing officer granted a fake adjournment of thirty days in order to circumvent limitation of adjudication. Landmark judgement requiring the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) FBR to streamline the record keeping of adjudication proceeding has been authored by the…
The Multan Bench of Appellate Tribunal Inland Revenue (ATIR) has issued a landmark judgment in an unprecedented case where an assessing officer granted a fake thirty-day adjournment to bypass limitation of adjudication. Comprising of Khurram Shahbaz Butt and Naveed Zafar Khan, the bench penned the decision. The case involved Muhammad Imran Ghazi, representing an appellant taxpayer, who argued that the impugned order was time barred as the thirty-day adjournment was never requested by the taxpayer.
Despite this, the ATIR required the officer to appear in person with records. Upon reviewing the order sheet, ATIR found that on November 20, 2025, the officer noted that Mr. Muhammad Amir, a firm partner, requested a thirty-day adjournment, which was subsequently granted. However, an affidavit from Aamer Tufail Warraich, a partner in the appellant firm, refuted the claim in the impugned order, stating that neither he nor any firm representative made any request for adjournment on that date.
The ATIR subsequently ordered the assessing officer to submit a counter-affidavit detailing the repercussions of failing to comply. The officer failed to provide the required affidavit, and ATIR concluded that as no actual adjournment was sought, the subsequent assessment order passed after 180 days of the show cause notice issuance is time barred.
The tribunal emphasized the importance of maintaining a true and contemporaneous order sheet for fair adjudication, as such entries undermine taxpayer rights. The ATIR forwarded a copy of the order to the Chief Commissioner of Inland Revenue for information and potential action as per the law. Tax consultant Shahid Jami commended the newly appointed ATIR members for their extensive tax law experience, highlighting their significant impact in delivering fair judgments and setting new precedents that are upheld by higher courts.
He also questioned whether the Chairman of FBR would take action against the assessing officer who manipulated official records to evade responsibility in multiple cases identified by ATIR.
Written by urgent.news from Business Recorder's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.