A disastrous doink, incoherent biopic Madden is just bad sketch comedy
Nicolas Cage's caricature of broadcast legend John Madden is confusing, but it's not even the worst part of David O. Russell's dismal comedy.
John Madden's life, a tapestry of Super Bowl victories, beloved sports commentary, and video game fortune, is the subject of David O. Russell's direct-to-Prime-Video biopic. However, the film is a disastrous doink, an incoherent attempt at capturing Madden's essence. Russell, known for acclaimed works like The Fighter and Silver Linings Playbook, seems to have lost his filmic touch here.
Nicolas Cage's portrayal of Madden, while ambitious, comes across as oafish, inarticulate, and delusional, a far cry from the genuine, jovial sportsman Madden was. Cage's heavyset physique and exaggerated facial features are reminiscent of his improv work, but they don't capture the real John Madden's charisma. Christian Bale's Al Davis offers a more grounded performance, but the film's disjointed narrative and Russell's inability to build emotional stakes make it difficult to connect with the characters.
The film jumps back and forth in time, with characters breaking the fourth wall to explain the plot, a lazy shortcut that hampers any potential for depth. Even John Mulaney's comedic portrayal of Raiders owner Al Davis and Cage's quirky take on Madden's markers and seagull philosophizing can't save Madden from its fundamental flaws.
Russell's direction seems more interested in shocking viewers with Cage's performance than telling a compelling story. While there are a few entertaining moments, like Mulaney's nerd-turned-football enthusiast and Bale's effective Al Davis, they are overshadowed by the film's overall ineptitude. Madden may be a so-goofy-it's-good experiment, but it's also laughably badly made. It's a Hail Mary that falls short, a 20-yards-too-short attempt at honoring a football legend.
Written by urgent.news from The A.V. Club's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.