Kerala High Court refers petition challenging clean chit to Chief Minister in Punarjani case to Chief Justice
High Court Registry directed to place the matter before the Chief Justice to decide whether the case would be considered by the court trying MP/MLA cases, Prevention of Corruption Act, or as a PIL
The Kerala High Court has referred a petition challenging the closure of the preliminary inquiry against Chief Minister V.D. Satheesan in the Punarjani case to the Chief Justice. Justice C. Jayachandran noted that the petition exhibited characteristics of a public interest litigation (PIL). The court directed the High Court Registry to present the matter to the Chief Justice for a decision on whether the case should be heard by the court dealing with MP/MLA cases, the Prevention of Corruption Act, or as a PIL.
The petition was filed by lawyer K.M. Shajahan, contesting a Vigilance and Anti-Corruption Bureau (VACB) report that ended the preliminary inquiry and dropped corruption charges against the Chief Minister in the context of the Punarjani flood rehabilitation scheme. During the court's consideration of the petition, it addressed two key points: whether the petitioner had the right to challenge the preliminary inquiry report and if the court had jurisdiction to hear the matter.
The petitioner claimed he filed the plea as a citizen and whistleblower, and had the right to challenge the report. The State argued that the petition was originally filed by one of the complainants in the Punarjani case, which was later withdrawn and re-filed as a PIL seeking a CBI probe. However, the Division Bench dismissed the PIL, contending that the petitioner lacked the right to move the petition since the complaint had been previously decided by the court.
The court determined that the issue of jurisdiction must be resolved before assessing the petitioner's rights.
Written by urgent.news from The Hindu's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.