How Milburn won over Labour on tackling rising youth unemployment
Labour grandee seems to have assuaged MPs’ nerves on need for welfare reform to tackle youth unemployment crisis In a boxing gym in Peterborough almost a year ago, Alan Milburn, freshly appointed to run a government review into the nearly one million young people out of work and education, said he would be “unafraid to shine a light on uncomfortable truths”. The Labour grandee, who had held three…
In a boxing gym in Peterborough almost a year ago, Alan Milburn, the newly appointed leader of a government review into the nearly one million young people out of work and education, declared he would be "unafraid to expose uncomfortable truths." As a Labour grandee who held three cabinet positions under Tony Blair, Milburn warned of a "downward escalator" taking young people into a "world of benefits" and vowed to provide radical solutions.
Many Labour MPs were skeptical, recalling their successful rebellion against the government's planned £5bn cuts to health and disability benefits, which had damaged Keir Starmer's political authority. Milburn knew he needed to win over MPs suspicious of his motives and concerned about the impact of changes on vulnerable individuals, even if some recognized that the rising welfare bill was unsustainable.
To gain their trust, Milburn made it a point to make the moral argument for change, speaking loudly and frequently about the issue. His key statistic – that the government spends 25 times as much on benefits for young people as it does on supporting them into work – became his rallying cry. Over the following months, Milburn engaged with MPs and held numerous interviews, describing projections of up to 1.25 million young people without work or education by the early 2030s without intervention as a "national failure."
He gradually signaled his intention to overhaul health and disability benefits for young people, emphasizing that the current system was exacerbating inactivity. Labour MPs were given time to adapt to the proposal and voice their concerns in public, with some controversial aspects of the report released early, including the abolition of health benefits for under-25s, including existing claimants.
Milburn worked well due to several factors: as Starmer's weakened position made it easier to "bulldoze" Downing Street into supporting his proposals, several welfare rebels were now in government, and the growing alarm over the prospects of the next generation, including concerns over mental health, social media, and AI disrupting the job market.
Burnham has pledged to cut the welfare bill as soon as possible without resorting to "crude cuts" that the government would struggle to get past Labour MPs. Milburn's approach echoes Tony Blair's "hand up, not a hand out" philosophy, advocating for welfare reform to reduce the "bills of social failure." The key difference now is the more challenging fiscal backdrop, but Milburn will recommend short-term spending on back-to-work support in exchange for welfare savings, increased tax receipts, and a fairer, happier country in the long term.
Choosing a boxing gym for his first promotional visit last year symbolized the fight Milburn believed the government needed to have. Milburn's recommendations, along with those from the Timms review on health and disability benefits, will form the basis of a white paper next spring, ultimately becoming a new welfare bill for Labour MPs to vote on.
Written by urgent.news from Guardian Business's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.