How an AI Content Mill Put a Real Musician Through Copyright Hell
‘I can’t get in touch with a human being.’ A company founded last year said it owns the copyright on an artist's five year old recording.
Samantha Shokin, a writer and musician, discovered her cover of a public domain Bulgarian folk song had been copyright struck on YouTube. She assumed it would be simple to resolve, but her journey led her to uncover an AI content mill that had abused YouTube's automated copyright detectors. The mill operates 500 low-quality channels, generating sloppily produced content that exploits YouTube's automated systems.
Initially, Shokin's 50-second version of "Bre Petrunko" gained traction on SoundCloud, where it remained unnoticed by copyright issues. However, two years later, when she uploaded it to YouTube, it started attracting attention from DJs and electronic artists, who sampled her cover in numerous tracks. Shokin noticed her music being used without her consent, which left her feeling violated and deprived of the royalties she deserved.
In an attempt to rectify the situation, Shokin reached out to the distributor, Loopmasters, who apologized and promised to address the issue by granting her royalties. While this provided some relief, the problem persisted, as her original recording was eventually taken down by a company called Media Nov Records. Media Nov advertised itself as a rights management and copyright protection company, but its website focused heavily on automated systems and minimal human interaction.
YouTube's automated copyright system tends to approve claims automatically, leaving the original uploader with limited options. Shokin filed two counterclaims, but both were denied. She tried contacting Media Nov, but struggled to reach a human representative due to an unresponsive phone line. Despite Loopmasters' assistance in contacting Media Nov, Shokin found herself ignored by both parties.
Media Nov's website boasted of its AI-powered content recognition and DMCA takedowns, claiming to safeguard artists' creations. However, its basic design and minimal online presence raised suspicions. The company's two addresses (one in Los Angeles and another in Dublin) were both unresponsive to phone calls, and its founding date was disputed, with conflicting information in corporate paperwork.
404 Media found four YouTube channels managed by Media Nov Records, each containing hundreds of low-effort, AI-generated electronic beats. These channels generated minimal views and featured few YouTube shorts revolving around "random acts of kindness." The combination of Media Nov's opaque operations and YouTube's reliance on automated systems highlighted the way AI can be weaponized against human creators, leaving them stranded in a copyright nightmare.
Written by urgent.news from 404 Media's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.