Concurrence : l’UEFA et une fédération de grands clubs de football européens visées par une plainte
L’Union des clubs européens estime que l’accord d’exclusivité conclu entre l’UEFA et une puissante organisation de clubs de football enfreint le droit européen de la concurrence.
The European Union Football Association (UEFA) and the European Clubs' Association (EFC) are being sued by a young organization representing non-premium teams for antitrust violations, according to a complaint filed with the European Union on Monday. The Union of European Clubs (UEC) challenged an agreement that recognizes the European Football Clubs Association (EFC) as "the sole representative" of the continent's clubs.
The UEC seeks European Commission scrutiny to determine if the exclusive agreement breaches EU rules on anti-competitive agreements and abuse of dominant position. The UEC argues that exclusive representation, coupled with "unequal voting rights" within EFC, allows dominant clubs to influence rules affecting the entire European football pyramid, helping elite teams like Paris Saint-Germain or Bayern Munich to maintain their advantage in a sector generating tens of billions of euros in annual revenue.
Dennis Gudasic, UEC's executive director, stated that "the question is simple: who has a say in the rules determining each club's future? Today, a single organization holds this power for all European clubs, while most of them have no real influence." However, convincing Brussels to open an investigation will be challenging. The Competition DG, the powerful EU body responsible for enforcing competition rules, has been reluctant to open investigations into football-related cases, considering them politically toxic, according to current and former top officials.
UEFA also enjoys good relations with the EU Commission. Its president, Aleksander Čeferin, and European Sports Commissioner Glenn Micallef renewed a cooperation agreement during a meeting in Nyon, Switzerland, last week. In contrast, the relationship between Brussels and FIFA is typically frosty, according to three current and former EU officials.
Nevertheless, Brussels has shown reluctance to initiate a formal competition inquiry against FIFA over its international match calendar, despite pressure from European lawmakers. UEFA stated in a press release, "UEFA's mission is to ensure European football as a whole." "We achieve this through an inclusive governance model, which includes all stakeholders: national associations, leagues, clubs, players and fans all have a voice, and decisions are made through dialogue and compromise.
Under this governance model, the UEFA-EFC memorandum of understanding, publicly accessible since 2008, provides a stable and transparent framework for cooperation with clubs across Europe. It ensures that participating clubs genuinely participate in all decisions regarding European club competitions." When contacted by POLITICO, EFC did not respond to our requests for a comment at the time of publication.
Miguel Maduro, a former Advocate General at the European Court of Justice and former president of FIFA's governance committee, advised the UEC in its complaint. The regular critic of current European and global football governance believes this case aims "to use EU competition law to protect the European sporting model, characterized by truly open and balanced competitions."
"A system in which a restricted group of elite clubs is granted the power to decide who can participate in European competitions and how revenues are distributed harms not only competition in European and national football. It gradually destroys the open and balanced competition model that UEFA itself claims to protect," Maduro added.
The UEC's argument partly stems from the 2023 European Court of Justice ruling concerning the Super League. They argue that the principles governing UEFA's approval of competitive competitions should also apply to its agreement with EFC. "Anyone controlling access to European football must do so based on transparent, objective, and non-discriminatory criteria.
An agreement that requires clubs to be represented exclusively by a single association in which most have no voice, and excludes clubs that belong to another association, does not meet these criteria," Maduro declared. EFC's rules prohibit its members from joining other transnational organizations representing clubs unless they are recognized by EFC, FIFA, or UEFA.
The UEC claims that small clubs have no significant influence within EFC, which currently has 920 members in both men's and women's football and is led by powerful Qatari executive Nasser al-Khelaïfi. EFC states on its website that all members can elect representatives to its board and other decision-making bodies. In April 2023, when the UEC was launched, Margaritis Schinas, then European Commission Vice-President, supported the organization.
"I don't consider this a problem or a fragmentation factor," he told POLITICO at the event. "It's actually a good thing." The UEC asserts that one club was warned in May 2024 that it would lose its status.
Written by urgent.news from Politico EU's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.