Can Economic Populism Survive an Age of Scarcity?
A number of candidates who prevailed in the last U.S. election can rightly be called populist in the 19th-century "prairie populist" mold, opposing monopolies and concentrated power, championing the rights of the average citizen, and opposing tariffs which hurt farmers and consumers. Perhaps the senator-elect from Texas, James Talarico, provided the clearest populist message by saying that the…
In the post-election landscape of the United States, a number of elected officials can be classified as populists, reflecting the sentiments of the common citizen. Texas Senator-elect James Talarico encapsulated this sentiment by asserting that the primary rift in the nation is between the wealthy and the economically disadvantaged.
The populist solution is to redistribute wealth and power, thereby improving the lives of ordinary citizens. This can be achieved through the expansion and subsidization of essential services such as healthcare, transportation, and education, making them more accessible and affordable. Additionally, increasing taxes on the affluent while maintaining or reducing taxes for middle and lower-income earners is another potential remedy.
The late 19th century was marked by robust economic growth, and redistributive measures in this era would have occurred within an expanding economic pie, benefiting both the affluent and the underprivileged. However, today's populists, or progressives as they prefer to be called, are grappling with an emerging age of scarcity, which is expected to complicate the redistribution of wealth and power.
This scarcity stems from limited resources needed to sustain modern society, including fossil fuels, metals, agricultural products, water, and the infrastructure these inputs enable. The factors contributing to this scarcity include the COVID pandemic's disruption of supply chains, the Russia-Ukraine conflict, and the Iran crisis.
In healthcare, prospects for addressing the issue include potential rescissions of Medicaid cuts, Medicare spending limits, and the reinstatement of subsidies for health insurance purchased through Affordable Care Act exchanges. While these measures are likely to be welcomed, they may exacerbate medical cost inflation and put additional strain on scarce resources.
The American healthcare system is the most expensive globally but yields inferior outcomes compared to most wealthy nations. Consequently, a redefinition of healthcare is necessary to prioritize the outcome of health over illness care. This might require a shift in dietary habits, as proposed by proponents like Robert Lustig, who advocate for a return to real, unprocessed foods like those endorsed by Lustig's Metabolical.
In the realm of transportation, the concept of automobiles as a service is no longer sustainable in an age of scarcity. As resources become increasingly limited, alternative modes of transportation must be explored, focusing on affordability and environmental sustainability. In the field of education, the concept of an educated person must be redefined.
Rather than focusing solely on specific fields of study, the goal should be cultivating individuals capable of participating fully in civic life. This includes governance, commerce, informed consumer behavior, aesthetic appreciation, and recreation.
Written by urgent.news from OilPrice's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.