Vote for IndyStar girls soccer Player of the Year

As the 2026 IHSAA girls soccer season concludes, IndyStar is inviting fans to participate in the Player of the Year fan poll. The poll will close on Friday at noon, allowing supporters to cast their vote. This recognition is purely fan-based and distinct from the IndyStar Player of the Year and the Indiana Soccer Coaches Association Player of the Year. Athletes are listed in alphabetical order by last name.

Isabella Cueto from Carmel played a pivotal role as a senior, contributing to a 12-3-1 record as a Greyhound. Hannah Dodge of Hamilton Southeastern, an undefeated Class 3A state champion, made 45 saves in 23 games, conceding only eight goals. Jocelyn Franklin from Center Grove, who guided the Trojans to the 3A state title game as a sophomore, scored 21 goals and provided seven assists.

Brooklyn Gibbons of Noblesville, a Ball State commit, helped the Millers achieve a 10-4-4 season record, logging 1,349 minutes of playing time.

Grace Huckaba from Covenant Christian stood out with 26 assists and 15 goals, leading a Warriors team that went 12-7. Leah Hunsucker from Westfield, a starting goalkeeper during her junior year, conceded 15 goals while the Rocks posted a 15-3-1 record. Joslin Kershaw, a verbal commitment to Miami University, led Park Tudor with 18 assists and second-most goals with 18, contributing to a 14-3-3 season. Mia Marlin from Center Grove scored a team-high 27 goals and provided nine assists for a 3A state runner-up Trojans team.

Addison McClain of Hamilton Southeastern, a Ball State commit, tied for second on the team with 15 assists and scored 10 goals for a 3A champion. Sydney May and Sydney Shattuck from Hamilton Southeastern each scored 27 goals, with May also dishing out 12 assists. Skylar Mueller from Hamilton Southeastern, a Colorado commit, led the Royals in assists (16) and netted the second-most goals with 24. Gwyneth Provost from Carmel made 34 saves in 13 appearances and conceded just 10 goals in her sophomore year.

Delaney Stone from Noblesville helped the Millers post a 10-4-4 record with nine assists and eight goals. Jaylin Taylor from Lawrence North scored a team-high 24 goals and provided six assists as a freshman, contributing to a 14-5-1 record. Rebekah Tekrony from Hamilton Southeastern tied for second on her team with 15 assists and scored 11 goals as a junior for a 3A state champion team.

Quinn Usher from Cathedral, a University of Akron commit, scored seven goals and provided six assists, leading the Fighting Irish to a 12-6-1 record. Avery Van Den Berg from Westfield, an Indiana commit, scored 13 goals and provided six assists during her senior season. Finally, Leila Wilson from Lapel led the Marian team with 40 goals and 15 assists, contributing to a 14-2-2 record.