Being Heumann Review

Being Heumann is a recently released film that chronicles the life of disability activist Judith Heumann. The movie, directed by Sian Heder, premiered on November 13 on Apple TV. Heumann's name is fitting for a story about the struggle to gain recognition for an underrepresented group. The film is based on Heumann's memoir, "Being Heumann," which has been turned into a biopic by Heder.

The story begins with a protest in 1972, which quickly turns into a series of events involving a coalition of protesters. The main character, Judy Heumann, played by Ruth Madeley, is a wheelchair user and one of several protesters who are frustrated with the Department of Health, Education, and Welfare's (HEW) Secretary Joseph Califano Jr. (Mark Ruffalo) for his refusal to sign a vital equality act into law.

The protesters include individuals who are blind, Deaf, para- or quadriplegic, and able-bodied allies from queer or racial advocacy groups like the Black Panthers.

Heumann's plan is to occupy the building until Califano Jr. signs the legislation, known as "Section 504." However, it is later revealed that Heumann had planned to stay overnight by packing a toothbrush. This self-absorbed behavior raises questions about her true commitment to the cause.

The film features an authentic and diverse cast, including Michael Patrick Thornton as Ed Roberts, a polio-stricken activist who cannot join Judy's plan due to his need for an iron lung. Thornton's performance is a standout, as he brings a sharp and sarcastic wit to his role. The entire cast, including Madeley, Ruffalo, Andrew Pilkington, and others, delivers powerful performances that bring the characters to life.

The tone of the movie shifts between challenging, comedic, and uplifting as it focuses on the in-group debates and conversations of the protesters. While the film does occasionally delve into prescriptive and verbose territory, this is a necessary part of Heder's storytelling approach, which aims to bring the complex political debates surrounding disability activism to the forefront.

The film's pacing and structure allow for a deep exploration of the characters' struggles and alliances, making it an engaging and thought-provoking watch. It is at its most interesting when the characters disagree, leading to a greater sense of cooperation down the line. The film also highlights the challenges faced by the protesters, such as the need for ramps, readers, and interpreters, as well as the broader societal issues that led to the protests in the first place.

Overall, "Being Heumann" is a powerful and authentic portrayal of a pivotal moment in disability rights history. The film's casting of disabled actors, coupled with its thoughtful storytelling, serves to amplify the message of the importance of equal access to jobs and education for all individuals, regardless of their abilities.