Should the Yankees non-tender Luis Gil?

In the span of two seasons, New York Yankees right-hander Luis Gil has experienced a dramatic decline in performance, hampered by injuries and struggling with his velocity and control. After a promising rookie campaign in 2024, where he was unanimously named American League Rookie of the Year, a severe lat strain in 2025 and shoulder issues in 2026 have significantly impacted his pitching.

In 2025, Gil posted a 3.32 ERA in 57 innings, but his peripherals were notably poor. In 2026, his workload was limited to just 39.1 innings, with a 4.61 ERA and a 7.12 FIP in 27.1 MLB frames, walking 18 batters and striking out 17.

As the Yankees prepare to decide whether to non-tender Gil before the November 20th deadline, the focus is on his ability to transition into a reliable bullpen role. While this role could offer a less strenuous workload, Gil's struggles with control and command make his potential success in the bullpen uncertain. His current level of performance, exemplified by his solid 1.50 ERA in six innings with the Tigres Del Licey in the Dominican Republic League, is a valuable asset, but his control issues remain a concern.

Trading Gil could yield some value, given his impressive rookie status, but finding a suitable match remains a challenge. If no trade materializes, the Yankees could give Gil a final opportunity in the bullpen or choose to release him without a contract, leading to a potential waiver release. However, Gil's lack of minor league options means he would face a difficult road ahead if the Yankees decide to cut ties.

Ultimately, the Yankees will have to weigh the risks and potential rewards, as there is little indication that Gil can sustain his previous level of performance over the long term.