I tried ChatGPT and Claude as my Android assistant; here's how they compare to Gemini

Google offers various AI apps, such as ChatGPT and Claude, that can be set as an Android device's default assistant. I tested each of them and compared their performance against Google's own Gemini assistant. After using each for a month, I have some observations to share.

Switching assistants on a Samsung Galaxy phone can be done through Settings > Apps > Choose default apps > Digital assistant app. A side key can also be assigned to act as the assistant. I found Claude performed better than ChatGPT in most everyday tasks. It could correctly calculate a tip, convert units, translate languages, and identify the capital of Australia. Claude's conversational tone was also more appealing, as it would keep listening for follow-up questions even after an initial response without interruption.

However, Claude lacked the ability to operate my device or control other apps. It couldn't send messages to my landlord, read messages aloud, or open Maps to provide directions. It could set alarms and timers, add Calendar events, and access some third-party apps like Canva and Notion. It also had the advantage of staying active after being woken with the power button, allowing continuous conversations.

In comparison, Google's Gemini assistant excelled at integrating with the device. It could perform a wide range of tasks, such as turning on the flashlight, saving reminders in Google Tasks, reading the screen, working on the lock screen, and even responding to voice commands with a wake word. Gemini is the only assistant that can fully utilize the phone's hardware features and has a convenient wake word for easy activation.

While ChatGPT and Claude are interesting AI assistants, Google's Gemini currently stands out as the most comprehensive Android assistant due to its seamless integration with device features and broader functionality.