Social Security Reform Looms Ahead
I graduated from college in 1982. Social Security was broke at that point, with promised payments exceeding incoming revenues. Since the system was “fixed” in 1983, the trajectory has been clear to me. I would pay into the system my entire working life, first to support those who were already retired or soon-to-retire in the … Continue reading Social Security Reform Looms Ahead The post Social…
In 1982, college graduate Mark Duggan observed that Social Security was insolvent, with promised payments exceeding incoming revenues. The system underwent a "fix" in 1983, but the trajectory was clear. Duggan explained that he would pay into the system throughout his working life, supporting retirees and building a "trust fund" for early retirees in the 2000s.
However, just as he approached retirement age, Social Security would again be insolvent, with promised payments exceeding projected revenues by $29 trillion over the next 75 years.
The actuaries predict that a 22% cut to all Social Security benefits will occur around 2032 under current law. Politicians will need to address this issue, but the lack of an answer means benefits may be cut. Duggan's talk at the National Bureau of Economic Research in July aimed to open up this conversation. He noted that relatively small changes taken decades ago could have preserved the program, such as the gradual increase in the full retirement age and the addition of payroll tax increases and benefit taxes for high-income earners.
Some potential solutions Duggan discussed include using general tax revenues to fill the gap, though this would change Social Security's core definition from a contributory system to one partially funded by general tax revenues. Other options include cutting benefits by phasing back the full retirement age, adjusting the formula for calculating benefits, tweaking the annual inflation adjustment, and raising the payroll tax rate to 17.3% to keep the program solvent until 2100.
However, raising the tax rate could push marginal rates well beyond 60% for high-income earners in states with high state tax rates, potentially reducing labor supply and other revenue. Duggan pointed out that the current structure of Social Security is not designed to withstand economic effects such as declining fertility, rising life expectancy, declining immigration, rising earnings inequality, and a declining labor income share.
He concluded that the arithmetic of Social Security reform is unforgiving, and politicians may turn to commissions or general tax revenues, potentially losing the opportunity for redesigning Social Security.
Written by urgent.news from Conversable Economist's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.