‘A Dog’s Perfect Christmas’ Review: The Dog Lives This Time! We Repeat, the Dog Lives!

There are two types of dog movies: ones where the dog survives, and ones where the dog perishes. Some viewers may find the latter more emotionally taxing, but the Netflix original "A Dog's Perfect Christmas" follows in the footsteps of the "Dog's [Blank]" franchise, ensuring that no canine lives or dies. The story focuses on a wealthy family facing everyday challenges.

Hunter (Milo Ventimiglia) is overworked, while his wife Juliana (Rebecca Staab) grows dissatisfied with their children, leading to potential marital strife. Their teenage daughter Ello (Brooke Lena Johnson) is dismayed by her upcoming spotlight at the Christmas parade, which is unseemly for various reasons. The film, directed by Cathryn Michon and co-written with the author W. Bruce Cameron, maintains a somewhat buoyant atmosphere despite tragic events.

Dennis Quaid's character, grieving his late wife, seems on the brink of suicide, but Michon handles it with tenderness. When Mom falls severely ill, succumbing to sepsis and slipping into a coma, her life-and-death ordeal forces the family to reevaluate their priorities. Dad becomes more attentive to his wife's wellbeing, Ello steps up at home, bonding with her grandfather, and starts dating The Local Studmuffin (Ethan Loomis).

Meanwhile, Grandpa starts dating multiple women, including Lucille (Jennifer Tilly) and Claire (Mary Steenburgen). Narrated by Winstead, voiced by Thomas Haden Church, the dog remains oblivious to the human drama unfolding around him. The film is not particularly profound, nor does it offer deep insights into canine cognition. Thomas Haden Church's narration doesn't add much nuance, and Winstead's impact on the plot is minimal.

The film's main appeal lies in the dog's perspective, but the dog's role is ultimately superficial. The human elements are a jumbled mix of emotions, and while some scenes are genuinely touching, the overall tone is bittersweet. Dennis Quaid delivers a surprisingly engaging performance, showing vulnerability and growth. Kathleen Rose Perkins handles her character with authenticity, capturing the family dynamic effectively.

Ethan Loomis, despite being a flawless character, is constrained by the script. While the movie is a typical Netflix Christmas film with a grim beginning, it ultimately becomes a comforting watch, boasting a polished production and an impressive cast. However, it falls short of being a standout dog or human movie, serving more as a filler piece to occupy viewers until a better film arrives.