Braves Must Fix Shortstop Hole And Pitching Depth Now

The Atlanta Braves face two critical issues heading into the 2027 season: a need to address a shortstop void and bolster their pitching depth. The front office must make tough decisions before the winter meetings commence. According to MLB.com, the team scored a 67 Weighted Runs Created Plus (wRC+) at shortstop, indicating the position's performance was 33 percent below the league average.

This significant deficiency poses a substantial threat to the Braves' hopes of winning another championship. Additionally, concerns exist regarding production at other positions, including third base (82 wRC+), left field (85 wRC+), and second base (85 wRC+).

The shortstop dilemma centers on Mauricio Dubón, who stepped in to fill the gap. Dubón's performance as shortstop this year was impressive, with a 115 wRC+ and a Fielding Run Value of +3. He displayed his capabilities in handling the position and hitting consistently. The Braves acquired Dubón through a trade following the Houston Astros' designation of Ramón Urías for assignment.

It is now imperative for the team to decide whether Dubón will remain at shortstop or revert to his typical utility role. The decision to keep him at shortstop appears to be the most logical choice, as it would address the most glaring offensive hole on the team. However, the next step would involve negotiating a new contract, as Dubón is a pending free agent capable of playing everyday shortstop duties.

On the pitching side, the Braves have a strong starting rotation anchored by Chris Sale, who posted a franchise-record 196 Adjusted ERA among pitchers with 25 starts. Sale's consistency, with his four-seamer clocked at 96.1 mph and a healthy season, is commendable. Yet, the team's rotation depth is limited to these three starters.

Additional signings, such as Tyler Mahle, could bolster their options, but it may not be sufficient. Young talent like AJ Smith-Shawver and JR Ritchie shows promise but require development before anchoring the rotation. The Braves must look beyond their roster to secure reliable pitchers if they aim to maintain Sale's workload and performance throughout the season.

Overlooking these issues will have severe consequences for the Braves in 2027. A shortstop who cannot contribute meaningfully will cripple the lineup from the outset. Furthermore, a pitching rotation lacking depth could wear down Chris Sale prematurely, diminishing his effectiveness in the postseason. In contrast, the 2021 championship team boasted depth at every position, highlighting the importance of addressing these deficiencies to preserve the team's competitive window.

With the World Series commencing on Friday, the Braves must prioritize these critical areas now to ensure their continued success.