The darkly funny Phony gives the doppelganger-mom genre the series-length treatment
Hulu's Phony distinguishes itself from the other Other Mommys with its unusual blend of mystery and teen comedy.
When a teen wakes up to find his mother replaced by a doppelganger, it's a premise that's seen in horror films like Goodnight Mommy and Other Mommy, and more recently Hulu's Phony. Only Phony adds a twist: the hero is a teenager on his way to losing his virginity. After crashing his car, Sonny Cooke (Sam Nivola) discovers his mother, Ellen (Connie Britton), looks slightly different when he wakes up in the hospital.
Ellen, Ellen 2, isn't immediately recognized as a stranger by those around him, but he knows something's off. The mystery of his real mother's whereabouts drives the plot, while Sonny navigates teen comedy and a mystery that's rarely coy about its developments. The show balances teen drama with mystery, delivering dark laughs and unique dialogue.
Connections to other shows like Pretty Little Liars and Twin Peaks are visible, but Phony also feels reminiscent of American Vandal. The cast, particularly Nivola, Britton, and Brennan, bring depth to their roles. However, the show occasionally loses focus on the central mystery, with subplots feeling underdeveloped. The love triangle with Chloe and Mallory, and the friendship with Vogel, both feel underexplored.
The show hints at a darker aspect to Sonny's charm, but doesn't delve deeply into it. The first four episodes set up a compelling mystery, leaving open whether it will conclude as a miniseries or continue as a teen comedy with a mystery element. The ending will reveal whether the dark tone will persist, or if Phony will lighten up its approach as it uncovers the truth.
Written by urgent.news from The A.V. Club's reporting — not their text. Machine-written — may contain errors; check the original before relying on it.
