Democrats say Netanyahu is the problem - but their opposition to Israel runs deeper - opinion

Democratic leaders and activists have consistently criticized Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to appease a radicalizing segment of their base, while simultaneously maintaining support for the United States-Israel relationship. Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer called for Israeli elections in March 2024, stating that a change in leadership would remedy the strained alliance. Senator Bernie Sanders went further, accusing Netanyahu's government of conducting an immoral and illegal war.

Progressive groups have long labeled the Israeli government as the most extremist, racist, homophobic, and far-right in Israel's history. These accusations imply that the issue can be resolved by voting out the current leadership. This strategy allows Democrats to appease one faction without openly challenging the very existence of the Jewish state.

However, a significant portion of the Democratic base has moved beyond conditional support for Israel, viewing the state and its existence as problematic. Activists have taken the argument to a new level, rejecting the very idea of a Jewish state "between the river and the sea." While Democrats continue to provide aid and affirm the alliance, the underlying support for the state is increasingly challenged.

Ultimately, Democrats must decide whether their support for Israel is grounded in principle or tied to the mood of a faction demanding more extreme action. As Netanyahu's term ends, the question remains: are they drawing a line around one man or moving toward a break with the alliance itself? The answer will determine the future of the Democratic Party's stance on Israel.