Kelly Clarkson vs the New York shop that wouldn’t sell her a bird

NEW YORK, Oct 12 — Singer and television personality Kelly Clarkson found herself in a public dispute with Brooklyn shop Art of Play after she posted on social media about being treated like she couldn't afford their products. The conflict began when Clarkson visited the store with the intention of purchasing a singing, dancing bird automaton called the Singing Bird, which was priced at $15,000 (RM61,300).

She claimed that the staff at Art of Play made her feel as though she couldn't afford the item, despite the price being clearly displayed.

Clarkson's post received widespread attention, garnering over 39.9 million views. In response, Art of Play clarified on Instagram that the particular bird automaton on display, named Molly, was part of their magic shows and therefore not for sale. The shop expressed that Clarkson's account of her experience resonated with many who have felt judged in a retail setting, emphasizing that they welcome both browsers and buyers. The company also expressed surprise at the significant online backlash.

Clarkson responded sarcastically to the situation, sharing an image that appeared to show the bird automaton on display with a price tag. She accused the shop of lying about the availability of the item and criticized their behavior. Clarkson defended her stance, stating that while she supports small businesses, they should not treat customers unfairly simply because of their size. She also mentioned that she rarely criticizes others and praised the store owner as cool.

Public opinion on the matter was divided. Some X users accused Clarkson of using her fame to target a small business over a single employee's behavior, while others supported her, arguing that the shop's staff should not have presumed her inability to afford the product. The shop, in turn, chose to respond with a calmer tone, thanking their supporters and welcoming further inquiries, while promising to handle the situation privately.