LCS ‘better than nothing’ despite prolonged delays, say experts

Defence analysts assert that despite the prolonged delays and ballooned costs, the controversial littoral combat ship (LCS) project will still provide the Malaysian navy with crucial and relevant assets. While some suggest the ships may be outdated by the time of delivery, experts Lam Choong Wah and Salawati Mat Basir maintain that the LCS will significantly enhance the navy’s capabilities.

Lam, of Universiti Malaya, acknowledges that certain systems and platforms may lag technologically, but stresses that the project is not a 'white elephant' and still enhances naval capabilities. Salawati, a maritime affairs expert from Universiti Kebangsaan Malaysia, emphasizes the critical need for the LCS project, acknowledging the project's setbacks but asserting that alternatives are not available.

The LCS project, originally costing RM9 billion, has expanded to RM11.22 billion due to delays and cost overruns, with the number of ships to be delivered reduced from six to five. The auditor-general’s report suggests the first LCS ship (LCS 1) might not be fully operational until December 2035, a claim disputed by Defence Minister Khaled Nordin.

Analysts call for a royal commission of inquiry (RCI) to investigate the project, alleging sensitive documents are inaccessible to even the Public Accounts Committee. They also advocate for increased transparency and oversight in future defence procurements, suggesting listing major procurements in the federal budget and subjecting those over RM100 million to parliamentary oversight.