Yankees' 'offseason focus' should include David Bednar, Paul Blackburn

The New York Yankees face crucial roster decisions heading into the offseason. The biggest question revolves around whether to re-sign second baseman Jazz Chisholm Jr. for the foreseeable future, as he may be the team's most valuable asset. However, the pitching staff and bullpen stand out as the biggest needs.

Several key pitchers from the Yankees' rotation will become unrestricted free agents this winter, leaving the bullpen particularly vulnerable. Tim Hill, Paul Blackburn, Ryan Yarbrough, John Schreiber, Michael Fulmer, and closer David Bednar are all likely to seek new contracts. Pitching ace Fernando Cruz is also a question mark, as he battles a partially torn UCL without surgery.

Given the depth of the Yankees' pitching staff, keeping Bednar as the closer should be the primary focus for general manager Brian Cashman. Bednar's impressive season, with 35 saves and a 2.47 ERA, positions him as a high-value asset. The Yankees might face a qualifying offer of around $23.1 million, but it seems likely that Bednar will decline it in order to secure a four-year, $66 million contract.

In addition to Bednar, the Yankees should also prioritize re-signing pitcher Paul Blackburn. Blackburn's dominant performances, including scoreless streaks and a 16-earned run total over 85 innings, make him a valuable commodity. His modest $2 million salary in 2026 belies his impact on the mound. Retaining Bednar and Blackburn would serve as the Yankees' top priorities in shaping their bullpen for the upcoming season.