Urgent.News

What's breaking now, across hundreds of outlets.

Finance & Markets

One Tax Loophole to Rule Them All

Pass-through income is the biggest source of inequality that no one talks about.

One Tax Loophole to Rule Them All

For 40 years, a significant number of wealthy business owners have utilized a tax concept known as pass-through income. This technique enables millionaires and billionaires to exempt their wealth from corporate taxation and protect substantial portions of it from income taxation, resulting in trillions of dollars in lost revenue for the government, exacerbating inequality, and forming a robust political opposition to reform.

Tax expert Daniel Reck from the University of Maryland emphasizes that this issue is "arguably the most important development in the tax system since the 1980s" and is crucial in understanding the rise of inequality. Democrats advocating for equitable taxation are unlikely to succeed without addressing pass-through income. The two-tiered tax system for businesses, established in the early 20th century, initially taxed the profits of small businesses as income for their owners and imposed a separate corporate tax on corporations.

However, during the Reagan administration, Congress reduced the top income-tax rate from 70 percent to 28 percent, below the 34 percent corporate-tax rate, while intensifying efforts to prevent tax evasion by corporations. As a result, many businesses opted to treat their earnings as income rather than corporate profits, allowing them to remain organized as S corporations or partnerships.

By doing so, they lost the ability to raise capital through public stock sales but gained a substantial tax advantage since S corps and partnerships are not subject to the corporate tax; their profits "pass through" to their owners as income. This seemingly minor change resulted in a profound transformation of the American business landscape.

In 1985, over half of U.S. employers were structured as traditional corporations. By 2015, this number had decreased to 16 percent, while the number of pass-through businesses tripled. The tax benefits of pass-through income extend beyond the corporate-tax exemption, encompassing a broader array of tax-avoidance strategies. For instance, flexible allocations allow businesses to distribute profits in a manner that minimizes their tax burden.

They may allocate profits from tax-advantaged investments to partners in higher tax brackets and allocate standard-operation profits to partners in lower tax brackets. Economists estimate that this technique alone has resulted in $250 billion in reduced tax revenue from 2011 to 2020, equivalent to the cost of a federal universal pre-K program.

In 2016, researchers at the Treasury Department and National Bureau of Economic Research analyzed millions of tax filings to determine the effective tax rate— the percentage of income a business pays in taxes— for different types of American companies. They discovered that the average corporation paid 32 percent of its profits in taxes, while pass-throughs paid only 19 percent.

Had the proportion of pass-throughs remained at its 1980 level, the U.S. government would have generated approximately $150 billion more in annual revenue, adjusted for inflation. In 2017, the Trump administration's tax bill further sweetened the deal for pass-through owners by allowing them to deduct up to 20 percent of their business profits, effectively rendering a fifth of their income entirely tax-free.

Within the first five years of this provision, pass-through owners claimed nearly $900 billion in deductions. Despite the rationale that pass-throughs primarily comprise small businesses and should not be burdened with excessive taxation, the number of partnerships with over 100 partners and assets exceeding $100 million surged from approximately 3,000 in 2002 to over 20,000 by 2019.

Today, pass-through businesses encompass some of the largest and most profitable companies in the nation, such as the principal funds controlled by the wealthiest individuals.

Rewritten by urgent.news; may contain errors — check the original.

Source: theatlantic.com

Read the original at theatlantic.com →

Report a problem with this story

More in Finance & Markets

More from Thursday 8 October →