LHC rules on plea against kids’ maintenance: Army pension not immune from attachment in family court decree
LAHORE: The Lahore High Court has ruled that a retired army officer’s pension is not protected from attachment, when it comes to enforcing a final maintenance decree issued by a family court in favour of minor children. A division bench, comprising Justice Malik Waqar Haider Awan and Justice Malik Javid Iqbal Wains, issued the ruling on a petition filed by Muhammad Latif, a retired army official,…
Lahore's Lahore High Court has declared that a retired army man’s pension is not safeguarded from attachment when enforcing a final maintenance order handed down by a family court for minor children. A two-judge panel, Justice Malik Waqar Haider Awan and Justice Malik Javid Iqbal Wains, announced the decision in response to a lawsuit brought by Muhammad Latif, a former army officer, against an additional district and sessions court’s ruling.
The wife of the petitioner had initiated legal proceedings against him for the dissolution of marriage and the recovery of dowry items. Meanwhile, his minor children requested maintenance payments. These cases were resolved in 2014, with the petitioner ordered to pay Rs3,000 monthly to each child, with the amount rising by 10 percent annually until the children’s marriage or change in custody. Both sides appealed the decree in 2015, but their appeals were rejected, making it final.
During the process of enforcing the decree, a family court in Jaranwala issued non-bailable arrest warrants against the petitioner and attempted to seize funds from his pension account. The petitioner’s attempt to have the warrants canceled and his pension released was denied in 2019. He then appealed to the high court. An initial hearing by a single bench found that two previous rulings from the Lahore High Court had reached conflicting conclusions on a related issue – whether the pension of a retired army officer can be attached in the execution of a family court maintenance decree.
The division bench, led by Justice Awan, ruled that Section 11 of the Pensions Act, which prohibits attachment of pension "at the instance of a creditor," does not apply to a family court maintenance decree for minor children. The bench reasoned that a child’s right to maintenance stems from the father-child relationship and the father’s inherent legal obligation to support his children, not from any loan, advance, or commercial transaction.
The family court decree merely quantifies and enforces this obligation, rather than establishing an ordinary debtor-creditor relationship. The bench also pointed out that Section 171 of the Pakistan Army Act specifically shields the "pay and allowances" of serving personnel from attachment by a "civil or revenue court," but does not extend to pension payments.
It noted that the family court, established under the Family Courts Act, 1964, operates independently from the civil courts covered by the West Pakistan Civil Courts Ordinance, 1962.
The judges also referenced Quranic teachings on a father's duty to provide for his children according to his ability, Pakistan’s commitment to Islamic principles under articles 2 and 2-A of the constitution, and classical Muslim personal law on a father’s maintenance responsibility. They noted that the petitioner had not demonstrated any legal or jurisdictional defects in the family court’s order.
They emphasized that simply possessing a pension does not prevent a judgement-debtor from having a final maintenance decree enforced against them. The bench dismissed the petition and directed the family court to proceed with the execution within 30 days of receiving a certified copy of the judgment.
Rewritten by urgent.news; may contain errors — check the original.
Source: dawn.com