Urgent.News

What's breaking now, across hundreds of outlets.

World

Beyond 16

EDITORIAL: The Punjab government’s decision to raise the age threshold under the provincial vagrancy law from 14 to 16 is a welcome, if belated, correction. The change acknowledges an obvious reality: young people involved in begging are often victims of circumstances and exploitation rather than perpetrators of a social nuisance. The tougher penalties for parents and guardians who involve…

Beyond 16

The Punjab government's recent decision to increase the age threshold for vagrancy laws from 14 to 16 is a welcome but insufficient step. The move recognizes that young individuals involved in begging are often victims of exploitation and societal factors rather than the cause of the issue. The new law also includes provisions for rehabilitation and stronger penalties against parents or guardians who involve children in begging. However, the reform does not go far enough in addressing the problem.

The new age threshold of 16 is not a clear solution. A 16-year-old is still vulnerable to coercion, exploitation, and abuse, just as a 15-year-old is. Although adolescents aged 16 and 17 may be more capable physically, they are still not adults and may lack the independence, resources, and protection needed to resist exploitation.

The amendment also strengthens administrative mechanisms for the law, including a proposed controller to coordinate anti-vagrancy operations, monitor welfare homes, and maintain a database. These measures could improve consistency and accountability if properly overseen.

The larger question remains: how should the state view children found begging? They should not be reduced to mere statistics in anti-vagrancy campaigns. Instead, their presence on the streets should prompt a response that includes protection, education, and rehabilitation, along with strict action against those exploiting children.

This is especially crucial for 16- and 17-year-olds. If the law acknowledges that minors under 18 can remain vulnerable and require special safeguards, there's no reason to exclude them from the vagrancy framework. A more consistent approach would be to treat all individuals under 18 as minors for protection against exploitation while placing enforcement responsibility on those who use them for begging.

Raising the threshold is a positive step, but the government should go further to ensure no minor falls outside the law's protective umbrella simply because they have surpassed the age of 16.

Rewritten by urgent.news; may contain errors — check the original.

Read the original at brecorder.com →

Report a problem with this story

More in World

More from Thursday 8 October →