Bekas senator menang saman fitnah terhadap Ramasamy selepas rayuan
Mahkamah Tinggi Pulau Pinang membenarkan rayuan Dr RA Lingeshwaran terhadap keputusan Mahkamah Sesyen yang sebelum ini menolak saman fitnahnya terhadap ketua Urimai itu.
The former senator, Dr RA Lingeshwaran, successfully challenged the High Court of Pulau Pinang's decision to dismiss his defamation suit against Urimai Chief, P Ramasamy. Lingeshwaran claimed that the High Court judge, Azlan Sulaiman, disregarded a previous April 30th ruling that had denied his defamation case and ordered him to pay a RM15,000 fee.
Instead, the court issued an injunction restraining Ramasamy from repeating or publishing the disputed statements at the heart of the lawsuit. The court also ordered Ramasamy to compensate Lingeshwaran with RM15,000 and return the case to Butterworth High Court to determine the amount of damages. Earlier, High Court judge Zulhazmi Abdullah ordered Lingeshwaran to pay RM15,000 after finding that Ramasamy successfully used self-defense and conditional protection in the defamation suit.
The lawsuit concerned two statements made by Ramasamy in a Malaysiakini article published on May 2nd, 2024, following a debate on the proposal to open a cardiothoracic surgery residency program at the University of Malaya (UiTM) in collaboration with the National Heart Institute (IJN). Malaysiakini received a response from Ramasamy regarding Lingeshwaran's objections to the proposal.
In these statements, Lingeshwaran accused Ramasamy of being mentally unfit and clearly wrong for suggesting the proposal. In his judgment, Zulhazmi decided that the first statement was not defamatory but rather political debate criticism. However, he found that the second statement could be considered defamatory because it touched on Lingeshwaran's professional medical reputation as a doctor, but was protected by the principles of honest opinions and conditional protection.
Zulhazmi also ruled that Lingeshwaran failed to prove that Ramasamy acted with malicious intent, as he was the sole witness and no other witnesses were called to prove the existence of such intent, either directly or through inference.
Rewritten by urgent.news; may contain errors — check the original.
Source: freemalaysiatoday.com
This story
This is one outlet's version. Read the fullest account.
- Bekas senator menang saman fitnah terhadap Ramasamy selepas rayuan freemalaysiatoday.com