Undang Yang Empat withdrew judicial review after MB signed proclamation, lawyers say
KUALA LUMPUR: The Undang Yang Empat have withdrawn their judicial review bid against Negri Sembilan Menteri Besar Datuk Ismail Lasim after he signed the proclamation they had sought.
KUALA LUMPUR: Undang Yang Empat have withdrawn their bid to challenge Negri Sembilan's Chief Minister Ismail Lasim through a judicial review, after he signed the proclamation they had sought, according to lawyers representing the Undangs. The application for a mandamus order was deemed academic, as the relief sought had already been fulfilled by Ismail's signature on August 3, stated Asmawi Ismail, Azam Aziz, and Emirul Sarifudin Nor Azmi.
The proclamation was later endorsed by the state government following a collective decision by the state executive council on September 15. The lawyers also noted that the matter was formally communicated to the Conference of Rulers through a letter from Ismail on September 21. Consequently, the relevant procedures under both the Negri Sembilan and federal constitutions had been satisfied.
The judicial review had been initiated to compel Ismail to sign the proclamation and to obtain a declaration confirming its validity under Article 10 of the state constitution. The lawyers dismissed claims that the proceedings aimed to determine the validity of the reigning ruler's position or to order a ruler's removal, stating that such interpretations would stray from the case's context.
Three former Undangs from Negri Sembilan and the current Undang of Johol had also withdrawn their judicial review application seeking an order compelling Ismail to sign the proclamation. The four, Datuk Mubarak Thahak, Datuk Maarof Mat Rashad, Datuk Muhammed Abdullah, and Datuk Abd Rahim Yasin, informed High Court judge Norliza Othman of their intent to withdraw the application after realizing it had become academic.
The court subsequently granted their withdrawal request. Regarding costs, the lawyers informed the High Court that the costs ordered were awarded to proposed interveners whose applications to intervene had not yet been heard, and that no costs were awarded to Ismail or the state government, who were the defendants in the judicial review.
The lawyers explained that costs following the withdrawal of a case were typically based on the expenses incurred by parties attending court and did not determine the merits of the case.
Rewritten by urgent.news; may contain errors — check the original.