Urgent.News

What's breaking now, across hundreds of outlets.

Health & Medicine

Medical negligence costs billions, but SA still can’t measure patient harm

Health-e News Medical negligence costs billions, but SA still can’t measure patient harm South Africa’s medical-negligence crisis is exposing failures far beyond individual doctors and nurses, with experts warning that weak leadership, poor adherence to clinical guidelines, inadequate documentation, staff shortages, and a lack of reliable data are allowing preventable harm to remain invisible.…

Medical negligence costs billions, but SA still can’t measure patient harm

South Africa's medical negligence crisis reveals systemic failures extending beyond individual healthcare workers, with experts warning that weak leadership, poor adherence to guidelines, inadequate documentation, staffing shortages, and unreliable data enable preventable harm to remain hidden. Despite a reported decline in medico-legal liability from R38 billion to R19 billion over five years in the Eastern Cape, experts caution that this reduced projected compensation does not equate to fewer patients suffering harm.

Former Health Ombud Professor Malegapuru William Makgoba stresses that South Africa still lacks a reliable national figure for patient deaths or serious harm due to healthcare failures. Professor Alex van den Heever, chair of Social Security Systems Administration and Management Studies, frames the medical-negligence liability as a warning sign about healthcare delivery rather than merely a financial issue.

The South African Medical Legal Association's annual conference in Gauteng will delve into medico-legal risk, patient safety, and accountability in healthcare. National Treasury estimates provincial medico-legal contingent liabilities at R57.6 billion for 2024/25, down from R62.5 billion the prior year. Actual provincial settlements average around R1.5 billion annually.

The Eastern Cape has attempted to mitigate its exposure by offering some injured patients future care in public facilities instead of paying large sums for anticipated medical and rehabilitation costs, but this approach hinges on the state's ability to deliver promised care throughout the patient's lifetime. A recent Supreme Court of Appeal judgment highlighted this risk, overturning a decision to substitute public healthcare and promises of compensation for a child injured through negligence due to the lack of assurance that lifelong treatment and future payments would be reliably provided.

The scale of medico-legal claims has spurred government intervention, with the South African Law Reform Commission initiating an investigation into medico-legal claims following requests from the Department of Health and the Minister of Justice and Correctional Services. The commission's final report and proposed legislation were released on September 29.

In the realm of maternity care, Dr Luleka Gcawu's research in the Eastern Cape illustrates how failures at ward level can escalate into medico-legal cases. Instances of inadequate intervention for abnormal blood pressure, missed responses to abnormal fetal heart rates, suboptimal monitoring, and unrecorded observations are common.

Gcawu's findings indicate that behavioral factors, such as poor patient relationships and inadequate response to identified problems, alongside system pressures, contribute to more than half of the factors leading to litigation. National Department of Health data shows South Africa's institutional maternal mortality ratio at 105.2 deaths per 100,000 live births in 2023, with the Western Cape at 71.8 and other provinces ranging from 101.5 to 166.6.

Identifying and addressing failures in maternal healthcare is crucial to preventing injuries and substantial medico-legal claims.

Rewritten by urgent.news; may contain errors — check the original.

Also reported by 1 other outlet

Every outlet that reported this, and when →

Read the original at health-e.org.za →

More in Health & Medicine

How Ebola Outbreak Affects Social Life

An Ebola outbreak can affect much more than people’s physical health. Because the disease can create fear of infection and require strict public health measures, it can change how people interact…

More from Wednesday 7 October →