Insurer denied stolen car claim over parking 500m away, man wins Rs 8 lakh payout
In a recent decision, the Delhi Consumer Commission ruled in favor of a car owner who had filed a theft claim against United India Insurance Company. The insurance firm had denied the claim, citing high mileage and the car's parking distance as grounds for rejection. However, the commission found these allegations to be baseless and arbitrary, without any substantial evidence to support them.
Naseem Ali, the car owner, parked his vehicle in February 2020, and it was later found stolen miles away. The insurer required multiple pieces of documentary evidence to support their claim, but failed to provide any credible proof. The car's mileage and a few toll deductions did not necessarily indicate commercial use. Additionally, the insurer did not prove that the vehicle was unlocked or that inadequate security measures were taken, as parking 500 meters away from the residence was insufficient to establish negligence.
The commission concluded that the insurer's rejection of the claim was deficient service and unfair trade practice, causing mental agony to the complainant. The insurer was ordered to pay Rs 7,74,005 with 7% annual interest and Rs 30,000 for mental anguish and litigation expenses.
Rewritten by urgent.news; may contain errors — check the original.
